We test and rank the best eyeliner using real-world data, expert analysis, and verified user feedback.
Showing 19-25 of 25 rankings
Verified reviews
Verified reviews
Verified reviews
Verified reviews
Verified reviews
Verified reviews
Verified reviews
| Product | Overall score | Category | Best for | Review |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner Review: Waterproof 2-Pack | 84 | Eyeliner | Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a long-wear pencil eyeliner designed for defined everyday eye makeup, with smooth application and strong pigment as its main draws. The 2-pack format also helps its value case. Its main limitations are mixed smudge-proof reliability for some users and a soft pencil that can break if overextended. | Open |
| REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner Review | 84 | Eyeliner | REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a long-wear pencil eyeliner designed for defined everyday eye makeup and smudged liner looks. It stands out for strong colour payoff, smooth application, and good value, though durability and eye-area tolerance appear less consistent across users. | Open |
| Maybelline Hyper Easy Eyeliner Review: Waterproof Pen | 82 | Eyeliner | Maybelline Hyper Easy is a liquid pen eyeliner designed for precise black liner looks with a satin finish and waterproof positioning. It stands out most for smooth application, control and value, though wear consistency and cap or tip reliability appear more mixed than its strongest reviews suggest. | Open |
| NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Black Bean Review: Eyeliner & Shadow | 84 | Eyeliner | NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Black Bean is a budget eye makeup product designed to work as an eyeliner, creamy eyeshadow and highlighter-style pencil. It stands out for smooth application, versatile use and strong colour performance, but the awkward sharpening and product-access design is a clear limitation. | Open |
| NYX Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil Review: Smokin Topaz | 86 | Eyeliner | NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil is a retractable eyeliner designed for quick, defined eye looks with creamy, vivid colour payoff. This Smokin Topaz brown shade appears especially suited to everyday wear or softer liner looks. Its main limitation is uneven wear performance, as longevity and smudge resistance receive mixed feedback. | Open |
We score each product across visible results, compatibility, ingredient quality, usability, packaging, brand trust, and value, then compare results within the category.
Featured guide
Our guide walks through key features, metrics, and tradeoffs.
Read the guide