CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner is a black liquid eyeliner pen designed for precise, matte eye looks, especially wings and defined lash-line detail. It stands out for rich pigment, easy control, and strong value, though waterproof wear and pen reliability appear less consistent for some users.
Expert reviewed
82
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner is a waterproof-style liquid eyeliner pen aimed at users who want sharp, defined eye looks with a matte black finish. The listing highlights a slender, flexible brush tip that allows users to vary line thickness from fine detail to bolder wings with light pressure. Based on the review data, this product is positioned as an affordable makeup staple for everyday liner, cat-eye looks, and more graphic application. It appears to suit a broad makeup audience, from budget-conscious shoppers to users wanting an alternative to higher-priced liquid liners. Review feedback repeatedly points to strong pigmentation, smooth glide, and easy use, while also showing some variation in smudge resistance and waterproof performance. Vegan formula positioning, cruelty-free brand certification, and a major review count strengthen its appeal within mainstream eye makeup.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Number of Items
1
Age Range Description
All
Package Type Name
Tube
Manufacturer
NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc.
UPC
800897085605
Global Trade Identification Number
00800897085605
Manufacturer Part Number
800897085605
Model Number
K2387704
Container Type
Palette

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Language
English, English, English, English, English
Item model number
K2387704
UPC
800897085605
Manufacturer
NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc.

Scores breakdown

84 /100

Effectiveness

86 /100

Beauty results

78 /100

Skin compatibility

1 /100

Hair compatibility

72 /100

Shade range

85 /100

Finish quality

76 /100

Longevity

62 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • Highly rated for precise application with a slender flexible brush tip.
  • Deep black pigment and matte finish are consistently praised in reviews.
  • Strong value score supported by the low price point and high user satisfaction.
  • Easy to use for many buyers, including beginners, despite the precise tip requiring a light hand.
  • Many users report all-day wear with minimal smudging.
  • Vegan formula and cruelty-free brand status add useful ethical appeal.

Limitations

  • Waterproof performance appears inconsistent across reviews.
  • Some users report smudging, transfer, or fading on watery or oily eye areas.
  • Packaging and pen reliability appear mixed, with reports of drying out and cap issues.
  • Shade variety exists, but this listing is focused on black and the broader shade range is limited compared with some eye makeup categories.
  • The very fluid tip may be less forgiving for users with a heavy hand or unsteady application.
  • Ingredient quality data is limited beyond vegan and cruelty-free positioning.

Ideal user profiles

  • Users who want a budget-friendly black liquid eyeliner for sharp winged looks.
  • Makeup wearers looking for strong pigment and a matte finish.
  • Buyers who prefer brush-tip precision for thin or bold liner styles.
  • Shoppers who value cruelty-free and vegan makeup options.

Use cases

  • Creating precise cat-eye or winged eyeliner looks.
  • Everyday eye makeup with a defined matte black line.
  • Quick detail work close to the lash line.
  • Layering into soft glam or fuller eye makeup looks.
  • Budget-conscious makeup kits needing a reliable liquid liner option.
  • Users who want adjustable line thickness from one pen.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This product sits firmly in the makeup category, specifically within liquid eyeliners for eye definition. Its main role in a routine is to add shape, contrast, and precision around the eyes, whether for a minimal lash-line look or a more dramatic wing. Within the category, it leans toward affordable high-impact makeup: strong pigment, a matte finish, and a brush-tip pen format that prioritises line control over softer, smudged pencil-style effects.

Best for

This eyeliner is best suited to users who want a precise black liquid liner without paying premium prices. It makes the most sense for shoppers prioritising sharp wings, rich matte colour, and easy day-to-day application. Based on the scores and reviews, it also fits buyers who want strong value and generally high customer satisfaction, as long as they are comfortable with a very fluid brush tip and do not need universally reliable waterproof wear.

Not best for

It may be less suitable for users with very watery eyes, those who need highly dependable waterproof performance, or anyone frustrated by pen-format inconsistency over time. Some reviews mention smearing, transfer, drying out, and cap issues, so buyers wanting the most robust packaging or the longest-lasting wear under sweat and moisture may prefer to be cautious. It may also be less forgiving for users with a heavy hand during application.

Beauty results

The visible result is a defined matte black line with strong colour payoff and the potential for very sharp detail. Review feedback suggests it works well for both fine everyday liner and bolder winged looks, with a smooth, fluid finish that many users find clean and even rather than patchy or flaky.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 84 , this eyeliner appears to perform well at its core job: creating defined liquid liner looks with strong control and noticeable pigment. The brush tip format, matte black finish, and repeated review praise for glide and precision all support that score. Many buyers say it stays in place well and works for both thin and bold lines. The main reason it stops short of a higher result is inconsistency around smudging and waterproof wear, especially for watery eyes or more demanding conditions.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 86 reflects one of this product's strongest areas. Buyers consistently describe a deep black, clean-looking result with good coverage and a defined matte finish. The eyeliner seems especially effective for creating sharp wings and crisp lash-line detail. While longevity is more mixed, the immediate cosmetic result is a clear strength.

Skin compatibility

With a skin compatibility score of 78 , the available evidence suggests generally solid tolerance for a makeup product used around the eye area, but not enough data to position it as universally suitable for sensitive users. Some reviewers mention no irritation and comfortable wear, including around sensitive eyes, while others mainly focus on smudging rather than discomfort. Full ingredient transparency beyond vegan positioning is limited here.

Shade range

The shade range score of 72 suggests acceptable but not standout variety. This listing focuses on black, which is the most common liquid liner choice and appears to perform strongly in reviews. Additional shades are mentioned in user feedback, including brown tones, but this is still a category where colour breadth matters less than in complexion makeup. Personalisation exists, though it is not a defining strength.

How it compares

Within the liquid eyeliner category, this product appears stronger than average for precision, black pigment, and value. It also stands out for broad customer approval, helped by a very large review base and strong ease-of-use feedback. Compared with many category options, it seems especially attractive for shoppers who want a brush-tip pen that can create clean, graphic lines without a premium price. Where it looks less dominant is consistency: some users get excellent all-day waterproof wear, while others experience smearing, drying, or cap issues. That makes it a high-performing mainstream option rather than the most dependable choice in every condition.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 82 , this product ranks as a strong affordable liquid eyeliner rather than an untouchable category leader. Its best-performing areas are value (92) , application (88) , customer satisfaction (88) , beauty result (86) , and finish quality (85) , which together explain its popularity. It delivers what many eyeliner users want most: sharp control, rich black colour, and a clean matte look at a low price. It ranks slightly lower than the very best options because wear consistency is mixed, and packaging/build concerns appear often enough to matter.

Buying advice

This eyeliner is worth considering if you want an affordable black liquid liner with a matte finish, strong pigment, and a brush tip capable of both fine detail and bold wings. It is a particularly practical choice for everyday makeup users who value precision and price. Be more cautious if you have very watery eyes, sweat heavily, or need consistently strong waterproof wear in all conditions. Before buying, check that a highly fluid pen format suits your skill level, review the ingredient list if your eye area is sensitive, and be aware that some users report drying or cap issues over time.
82
Overall score

Final verdict

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner is a strong option in the affordable liquid eyeliner category. Its main strength is the combination of precise application, rich matte black payoff, and excellent value, all backed by very high customer engagement and generally favourable feedback. Its main limitation is consistency: while many users get long-lasting, low-smudge wear, others report weaker waterproof performance and occasional pen reliability issues. If your priority is a budget-friendly liner for sharp eye looks, it is easy to recommend. If your priority is maximum wear security under watery-eye conditions, it may be more variable.
Back to review

Key topics

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, NYX Epic Ink Liner review, waterproof liquid eyeliner review, black matte liquid eyeliner, vegan eyeliner pen, drugstore liquid eyeliner, winged eyeliner pen, best affordable eyeliner, precise brush tip eyeliner, NYX eyeliner black

Frequently asked questions

Is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner good for winged eyeliner?
Yes, the product appears particularly well suited to winged eyeliner. Its flexible brush tip and high application score suggest strong precision, and many reviewers specifically mention sharp lines, easy detail work, and adjustable thickness for both subtle and bold looks.
Is NYX Epic Ink Liner truly waterproof?
The waterproof claim is only partly supported by the available feedback. Many users report very good wear and resistance to smudging, but others say it can smear or break down on watery eyes, sweat, or after several hours. Results seem to vary by eye area and wear conditions.
Is this eyeliner easy for beginners to use?
For many buyers, yes. Review feedback and the ease-of-use score indicate that it is generally simple to apply, especially thanks to the fluid pen format. However, some users note that the tip releases product easily, so a very heavy hand may make application less controlled.
How long does NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner last?
Wear time appears strong for many users, with frequent reports of all-day definition. Still, the longevity score is more moderate than the application score because some reviewers mention smudging, fading, or reduced hold on watery lids. In the pen itself, some users also report drying over time.
Is NYX Epic Ink Liner suitable for sensitive eyes?
Some reviewers say they experienced no irritation and found it comfortable around the eyes, but the available data is not enough to confirm universal suitability for sensitive users. If your eye area is reactive, checking the ingredient list and patch testing where appropriate is the cautious approach.
What finish does NYX Epic Ink Liner have?
This eyeliner is described as a matte black liquid liner, and reviews strongly support that look. Users frequently mention a deep, rich black result with defined lines rather than a glossy finish, which makes it a good fit for classic and graphic eye makeup styles.
Does NYX Epic Ink Liner offer good value for money?
Yes, value is one of its strongest areas. The product combines a low price with very high review volume, strong satisfaction, and repeated praise for pigmentation, ease of use, and performance. The main trade-off is that reliability around waterproofing and pen longevity is not fully consistent.
What are the main drawbacks of NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner?
The main concerns are inconsistent waterproof wear, occasional smudging on watery eyes, and mixed feedback on packaging reliability. Some users also mention the pen drying out, product flow issues over time, or cap problems, which can affect longer-term convenience.

Related Guides & Rankings

NYX Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil Review: Sm... NYX Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil Review: Sm... NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Black Bean Review: Eyeline... NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Black Bean Review: Eyeline... Maybelline Hyper Easy Eyeliner Review: Waterpro... Maybelline Hyper Easy Eyeliner Review: Waterpro... REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner Review REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner Review