CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil Black Bean Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Black Bean is a budget eye makeup product designed to work as an eyeliner, creamy eyeshadow and highlighter-style pencil. It stands out for smooth application, versatile use and strong colour performance, but the awkward sharpening and product-access design is a clear limitation.
Expert reviewed
84
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Black Bean is a creamy eye pencil designed for multiple makeup roles, including eyeliner, eyeshadow and highlighting. The brand describes it as a radiant, blendable formula made with a blend of mineral oil and powder, and customer feedback broadly supports the idea that it glides on smoothly with easy blending. In practical terms, this makes it suitable for quick eye looks, soft smudged liner, darker lid colour or as a base under powder shadow. With a low price point, very high review volume and a 4.3/5 average rating, it appears aimed at buyers who want flexible eye makeup without a high spend. The main issue is not the formula itself but the packaging format: repeated reviews mention confusion over how to sharpen it and how to access more product, which meaningfully affects convenience.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Number of Items
1
Age Range Description
All
Manufacturer
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
UPC
800897114992
Global Trade Identification Number
00800897114992
Manufacturer Part Number
NYX-JEP601
Model Number
JEP601
Country as Labeled
United States
Container Type
Palette

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
0.53 x 0.53 x 4.96 inches; 0.18 ounces
Item model number
JEP601
UPC
800897114992
Manufacturer
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP

Scores breakdown

86 /100

Effectiveness

88 /100

Beauty results

78 /100

Skin compatibility

20 /100

Hair compatibility

90 /100

Shade range

84 /100

Finish quality

78 /100

Longevity

68 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • Strong colour performance for an eye pencil, supported by a high beauty result score of 88.
  • Creamy, blendable formula is widely praised for smooth application without noticeable tugging.
  • Versatile format can be used as eyeliner, eyeshadow and highlighter.
  • Wide shade offering across multiple finishes supports strong personalization and shade range scores.
  • Large review volume and a 4.3/5 average suggest broad customer approval.
  • Cruelty-free positioning is clearly stated by the brand and supports its ethical transparency profile.

Limitations

  • Packaging is a major weak point, with repeated complaints about sharpening and accessing the remaining product.
  • Ease of use is limited by the non-twist design, especially for buyers expecting a standard retractable pencil.
  • Longevity appears mixed, with some users reporting all-day wear and others finding performance less consistent.
  • Pigmentation feedback is not fully consistent across reviews, so colour intensity may vary by shade or expectation.
  • Value perception is mixed because some buyers feel the format makes it harder to use the full amount of product.
  • Ingredient quality data is limited beyond the mention of mineral oil and powder, so deeper formula assessment is restricted.

Ideal user profiles

  • Makeup users who want a low-cost, multi-use eye pencil for liner, lid colour and inner-corner highlighting.
  • Buyers who prefer creamy eye products that blend quickly and apply with minimal pulling.
  • People building an everyday eye makeup kit with flexible shade options.
  • Users comfortable sharpening jumbo pencils rather than relying on retractable packaging.

Use cases

  • Everyday eyeliner looks.
  • Quick one-product eye makeup routines.
  • Inner-corner or waterline highlighting.
  • Using a creamy base under brighter powder shadows.
  • Soft smudged liner looks.
  • Travel makeup kits where a multi-use eye product is useful.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This product sits firmly in the makeup category, specifically within eye makeup. Its main role is to add colour and definition around the eyes, but it also overlaps with cream eyeshadow sticks because it can be applied across the lid and blended out. Within a routine, it fits best as a quick, multi-use eye product for simple looks, accent work or shadow base use. It is less about precision liquid-liner styling and more about creamy, adaptable eye colour.

Best for

This pencil is best suited to makeup users who want an affordable, flexible eye product with strong colour payoff and easy blending. It should appeal to people who like soft liner, quick lid colour or inner-corner highlighting without needing multiple separate products. Based on the scores and reviews, it is especially well suited to buyers who prioritise application feel and overall look more than premium packaging design.

Not best for

It may be less suitable for shoppers who strongly prefer retractable pencils, highly precise packaging, or very consistent long-wear performance. Buyers who dislike sharpening large plastic pencils may find the format frustrating, and those expecting uniformly intense pigmentation across every shade may want to manage expectations. If convenience and packaging usability matter as much as formula performance, this may feel less polished than some alternatives.

Beauty results

The visible result is one of this product’s stronger areas. In Black Bean, the format is suited to bold eye definition, smoked-out liner looks or creamy lid colour with a soft, blendable finish. Review feedback points to attractive colour, smooth laydown and a flattering eye-enhancing effect, although the exact intensity can feel more impressive to some users than others.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 86, this product appears to perform well at its core task: delivering easy-to-apply eye colour in a flexible pencil format. The brand positions it as a triple-use product for eyeliner, eyeshadow and highlighting, and customer feedback broadly supports that versatility. Reviewers frequently mention smooth glide, attractive colour and good usability on the eye area, including as a base for brighter shadows. The main concern is not formula performance but access to the full product, since the awkward sharpening design can make ongoing use less straightforward than expected.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 88 indicates that this pencil generally creates an appealing finished look. Customer feedback highlights gorgeous colour, good coverage and eye-brightening effects, especially when used strategically on the lid, waterline or inner corners. In Black Bean, the result is likely strongest for bold definition and soft smoky blending. Some mixed pigmentation feedback prevents this from looking fully consistent across all user expectations.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score of 78 suggests generally acceptable wear for an eye-area makeup product, but not a fully universal fit. A few reviews describe comfortable use and no irritation in personal experience, including around watery eyes, yet this remains anecdotal rather than conclusive. Since it is used close to the eyes and sometimes on the waterline, users with sensitivity should be cautious and monitor how their skin and eye area respond.

Shade range

The shade range score of 90 is a clear strength. While this page focuses on Black Bean, the product is described as coming in a rainbow of vivid hues and multiple finishes from matte to metallic. That broad colour offering makes the range more flexible than many single-purpose eye pencils. It also improves personalization, allowing buyers to choose between classic definition shades and brighter or lighter accent colours depending on their makeup style.

How it compares

Within the eye pencil and eyeshadow stick category, this product appears stronger than average for versatility, shade selection and visual payoff, especially at its price point. It compares well on application comfort and multi-use performance, making it attractive for buyers who want one eye product to cover several routine steps. It is less competitive on packaging usability and convenience, where the non-retractable format creates more friction than many shoppers expect. Overall, it stands out more for formula and colour experience than for product design polish.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 84, this NYX eye pencil ranks as a strong budget-friendly option in the eye makeup category. Its profile is driven by standout scores for shade range, beauty result, customer satisfaction, application and personalization, all of which support its reputation as a versatile, easy-to-wear product. The formula itself appears well liked, especially for smooth glide and flexible use as liner or shadow. What keeps it from ranking even higher is the very weak packaging quality score of 44 and a lower ease-of-use score of 60, both tied to sharpening and product-access frustration.

Buying advice

This product is worth considering if you want an affordable eye pencil that can double as liner and creamy shadow, especially if you enjoy blendable textures and flexible eye looks. It is a good fit for buyers who do not mind using a jumbo sharpener and who prioritise colour payoff and smooth application over premium packaging. You may want to skip it if you prefer retractable pencils, ultra-precise liner tips or very predictable long-wear results. Before buying, check the shade carefully, make sure you have a suitable sharpener, and be cautious if your eye area is particularly sensitive.
84
Overall score

Final verdict

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Black Bean is a strong option in the budget eye makeup category. Its main strength is the formula: it applies smoothly, blends easily and delivers a versatile eye look that can work as liner, shadow or accent colour. Its main limitation is the packaging, which is consistently criticised for being awkward to sharpen and unclear to use. For buyers who can tolerate that design issue, it offers good overall performance and wide routine flexibility. For buyers who want maximum convenience, it may feel more frustrating than its low price initially suggests.
Back to review

Key topics

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil review, NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Black Bean, blendable eyeshadow stick review, eyeliner pencil review, black eyeliner crayon, budget eye makeup, cream eyeshadow pencil, NYX eye pencil review, multi-use eyeliner and eyeshadow, cruelty-free eye makeup

Frequently asked questions

Is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Black Bean good for everyday eye makeup?
It appears to be a strong everyday option for simple eye looks. The formula is described as creamy and blendable, and the product’s 86 effectiveness score and 88 beauty result score suggest it performs well for regular eyeliner or quick shadow-style use. Packaging convenience is the main drawback.
Does NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil work as both eyeliner and eyeshadow?
Based on the product description and customer feedback, yes. It is positioned as a multi-use eye pencil for eyeliner, eyeshadow and highlighting, and reviews mention it working well for lid colour, waterline use and even as a base under brighter shadows.
How long does NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil last on the eyes?
Wear time appears mixed rather than fully consistent. Some reviewers say it lasts all day or around 4 to 6 hours, while others report more average staying power. Its longevity score of 78 suggests generally decent wear, but not the most reliable long-wear result in the category.
Is the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil easy to apply?
Application is one of its stronger points. The creamy texture is repeatedly praised for gliding on smoothly without much tugging, and the application score of 87 supports that. However, ease of use overall is lower because sharpening and accessing more product can be inconvenient.
What are the main limitations of NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil?
The biggest issue is packaging. Multiple reviews mention confusion over the non-twist format and difficulty sharpening or reaching the rest of the product. There are also mixed views on pigmentation, wear time and value, so expectations should be matched to the price and format.
Is NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil suitable for sensitive eyes?
The available data is not strong enough to confirm suitability for sensitive eyes in general. Some reviewers mention comfortable wear and no irritation in their experience, but that does not guarantee compatibility for everyone. If you are sensitive around the eye area, a cautious patch test is sensible.
Does NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil offer good value for money?
Value looks moderate rather than clear-cut. The price is accessible and many users like the performance, but the awkward product access affects value perception for some buyers. Its value score of 73 suggests it can be worthwhile if you are comfortable with jumbo-pencil sharpening.
Is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil cruelty-free?
The brand states that it is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free brand. That supports the product’s ethical transparency profile, which scored 86. No broader ethical or sustainability details were provided beyond that cruelty-free information.

Related Guides & Rankings

Maybelline Hyper Easy Eyeliner Review: Waterpro... Maybelline Hyper Easy Eyeliner Review: Waterpro... REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner Review REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner Review Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner Review: Waterp... Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner Review: Waterp... wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Eyeliner Review wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Eyeliner Review