CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner Review

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a long-wear pencil eyeliner designed for defined everyday eye makeup, with smooth application and strong pigment as its main draws. The 2-pack format also helps its value case. Its main limitations are mixed smudge-proof reliability for some users and a soft pencil that can break if overextended.
Expert reviewed
84
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a pencil-format eye makeup product aimed at users who want long-wearing definition with a straightforward application style. In this 201 Black 2-pack, the focus is on rich colour, everyday versatility and practical convenience, with a built-in sharpener and smudger included in the design. Product details describe waterproof, smudge-proof, fade-proof and transfer-proof wear for up to 24 hours, while review feedback broadly supports strong wear and pigmentation, though not with complete consistency. This eyeliner appears most suitable for adults looking for affordable daily eye definition without moving into a more complex liquid or gel format. Review sentiment suggests it performs especially well for smooth glide, bold colour and general staying power. The main trade-off is that the very soft pencil design can make breakage and precision issues more likely for some users.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Item details

Brand Name
REVLON
Number of Items
2
Age Range Description
Adult
Manufacturer
Revlon
UPC
309977809013
Global Trade Identification Number
00309977809013
Manufacturer Part Number
7259712201
Model Number
7259712201
Set Name
2

Item details

Brand Name
REVLON
Number of Items
2
Age Range Description
Adult
Manufacturer
Revlon
UPC
309977809013
Global Trade Identification Number
00309977809013
Manufacturer Part Number
7259712201
Model Number
7259712201
Set Name
2

Measurements

Number of Items
2
Item Weight
0.02 Pounds
Item Dimensions
1.94 x 0.63 x 5.75 inches

Product details

Product Dimensions
1.94 x 0.63 x 5.75 inches; 0.32 ounces
Item model number
7259712201
UPC
309977809013
Manufacturer
Revlon

Scores breakdown

86 /100

Effectiveness

88 /100

Beauty results

68 /100

Skin compatibility

1 /100

Hair compatibility

82 /100

Shade range

84 /100

Finish quality

89 /100

Longevity

66 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • Strong overall wear performance, with a high longevity score of 89.
  • Rich pigmentation and defined eye makeup result, supported by a beauty result score of 88.
  • Smooth glide-on application makes it easier to create subtle or more dramatic liner looks.
  • Built-in sharpener and smudger add practical versatility for everyday makeup use.
  • High customer satisfaction, backed by a 4.5/5 rating from more than 50,000 reviews.
  • The 2-pack format supports value for frequent eyeliner users.

Limitations

  • Smudge-proof and waterproof performance appears mixed in reviews despite strong wear claims.
  • The soft pencil tip can break if extended too far or handled too aggressively.
  • Some users report irritation, particularly when used on the waterline or very close to the eye.
  • Build quality is a weaker area, with a build quality score of 62 and durability score of 60.
  • The very soft texture may make ultra-fine precision lining harder for some users.
  • Ingredient transparency and ethical transparency are limited based on the provided data.

Ideal user profiles

  • Everyday makeup users who want a black pencil eyeliner with strong colour payoff.
  • Buyers looking for a budget-friendly long-wear eyeliner in a convenient 2-pack.
  • Users who like a pencil format with built-in blending and sharpening features.
  • People who prefer eyeliner that can create both soft smudged looks and more defined lines.

Use cases

  • Everyday eye makeup routines.
  • Long-wear eyeliner looks for work or events.
  • Waterline application, where tolerated by the user.
  • Soft blended liner using the built-in smudger.
  • Quick makeup bag touch-ups with an all-in-one pencil format.
  • Budget-conscious repeat eyeliner purchases.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This product sits firmly in the makeup category, specifically within long-wear pencil eyeliners. Its role in a routine is to define the lash line, deepen eye makeup looks and offer either a soft smudged finish or a more structured line depending on application. Compared with more rigid pencils or liquid liners, this product appears positioned as a convenient, easy-glide option for everyday wear, with added usefulness from the built-in sharpener and smudger.

Best for

This eyeliner is best for users who want a budget-friendly pencil eyeliner with strong colour payoff, easy glide and good day-to-day wear. It suits people building quick everyday eye looks, especially those who like a softer pencil texture and appreciate an integrated sharpener and smudger. The high value, application and longevity scores make it particularly appealing for repeat use.

Not best for

It may be less suitable for users who want the firmest possible pencil for ultra-precise lines, since reviews suggest the soft formula can break and lose shape easily. It may also be a less comfortable choice for very sensitive eyes or cautious waterline users, as irritation appears in some feedback. Buyers expecting completely consistent waterproof or smudge-proof performance should also keep expectations measured.

Beauty results

The visible result is a bold, defined eyeliner look with strong colour payoff and a finish that can range from softly blended to more dramatic. Reviews point to solid opacity and a polished eye makeup effect, especially in black and other richer shades. The main visual drawback is that if overapplied, the formula may look heavier, less precise or more prone to flaking for some users.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 86 , Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner appears to perform well at its main purpose: adding visible eye definition with strong staying power. Review sentiment consistently praises smooth glide, rich pigment and reliable wear through the day. The built-in sharpener and smudger also improve functional versatility. However, effectiveness is not flawless across all users, as some reviews report smudging, easier-than-expected removal or difficulty maintaining a precise tip. Overall, it looks like a strong performer in the affordable pencil eyeliner category, but not the most consistent option for every application style.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 88 reflects a strong cosmetic payoff. Reviews repeatedly describe the colour as bold, opaque and flattering, with the black shade delivering clear lash-line definition. The formula can also be blended for a softer effect before it sets. The main result-related downside is that the very soft texture may create thicker or less precise lines than some users want.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score of 68 suggests average compatibility rather than standout gentleness. The product is described as ophthalmologist tested and suitable for the waterline, and several users report comfortable wear. Still, at least one detailed review mentions eye irritation and redness, especially near the waterline. That means comfort around the eye area may vary depending on individual sensitivity.

Shade range

The shade range score of 82 indicates a solid level of choice for a pencil eyeliner. Product details state that the line is available in 12 wearable matte and shimmer shades, which supports some flexibility for everyday neutrals and more colourful options. The reviewed pack is the 201 Black version, so this page is centred on a classic deep shade rather than broader shade matching concerns.

How it compares

Within its category, this product appears stronger than many basic pencil eyeliners for colour payoff, all-day wear and value, especially given the 2-pack format and very high review volume. It also compares well on ease of application, which is important for users who find liquid liners too fiddly. Where it looks less competitive is structural reliability: a softer formula helps glide and blending but can work against precision and durability. The moderate ingredient and safety profile also means it does not clearly stand out as a sensitivity-focused option. Overall, it seems better suited to practical long-wear makeup shoppers than to users prioritising ultra-firm precision or maximum formula transparency.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 84 , this Revlon eyeliner ranks as a strong option in the affordable long-wear eyeliner segment. Its position is supported by standout scores for longevity, customer satisfaction, value, beauty result and application. In practical terms, it delivers what many buyers want most from a pencil eyeliner: bold colour, easy glide and dependable daily wear. It does not rank higher because some weaker areas remain clear, especially durability, build quality, mixed smudge-proof consistency and occasional eye irritation reports. Overall, its score profile points to a product that performs well for most users while still having a few formula-and-design trade-offs.

Buying advice

Consider this eyeliner if you want an affordable black pencil liner for everyday use, especially if smooth application, visible pigment and long wear matter more than razor-sharp precision. The 2-pack makes particular sense for frequent makeup users who repurchase eyeliner regularly. If your eyes are very sensitive, or if you often wear liner on the waterline, it is worth being cautious because irritation is mentioned in some reviews. Buyers who prefer a very firm tip should also note the breakage risk and softer texture. Before buying, it is sensible to check whether a softer, blendable pencil format matches your preferred eye makeup style.
84
Overall score

Final verdict

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a strong option in the drugstore eyeliner category. Its main strength is the combination of smooth application, bold colour and reliable long-wear performance at a low price, especially in this 2-pack format. The main limitation is the soft pencil design, which can reduce precision and lead to breakage or product waste. For most users wanting an everyday black eyeliner that is easy to use and holds up well, it looks like a sensible buy. For users with very sensitive eyes or a preference for firmer, ultra-precise pencil liners, it may be a less ideal fit.
Back to review

Key topics

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, Revlon eyeliner review, waterproof pencil eyeliner, smudge proof eyeliner, long wear eyeliner, black eyeliner pencil, drugstore eyeliner, eye makeup pencil, Revlon ColorStay black eyeliner, best affordable eyeliner

Frequently asked questions

Is Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner good for everyday makeup?
It appears well suited to everyday use. Reviews repeatedly mention smooth application, strong colour payoff and reliable all-day wear, and the product holds an overall score of 84. The built-in sharpener and smudger also make it practical for simple daily eye looks.
Does Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner really stay on all day?
Wear time is one of its stronger areas, reflected in a longevity score of 89. Many users say it stays put for long days, including in heat or humidity, but review feedback is mixed on smudge and waterproof reliability, so results may depend on application style and eye area conditions.
Is this eyeliner suitable for the waterline?
The product is described as ophthalmologist tested and suitable for use on the waterline. Some reviewers also say it works well there. However, one detailed review reported eye irritation, so comfort may vary and cautious users may prefer to test it carefully first.
Does the pencil break easily?
Breakage is a known limitation in the review data. Multiple users mention that extending the pencil too far can cause the tip to snap, and the durability score is only 60. The formula appears soft, which helps glide but can make the pencil more fragile.
Is Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner easy to apply?
Yes, ease of use is one of its stronger points, with an ease of use score of 85 and application score of 87. Reviews often describe it as smooth, creamy and easy to blend, although that same softness may make very thin, ultra-precise lines harder for some users.
Is the waterproof claim fully supported?
The claim support looks moderate rather than absolute, with a claim support score of 77. Many buyers report strong staying power, but others say it can smudge or remove more easily than expected for a waterproof eyeliner. The claim is partly supported by user experience, but not consistently for everyone.
Does this eyeliner offer good value?
Value is one of its strongest areas, with a value score of 88. The price point is low for a 2-pack, and many reviewers describe it as dependable and worth repurchasing. That said, any product waste from breakage can reduce value for some users.
Who is Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner best for?
It is best for users who want an affordable, pigmented pencil eyeliner for daily wear and simple application. It also suits people who like having a built-in sharpener and smudger. It may be less ideal for those who prioritise maximum precision or have very sensitive eyes.

Related Guides & Rankings

wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Eyeliner Review wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Eyeliner Review The Flick Stick Winged Eyeliner Stamp Review The Flick Stick Winged Eyeliner Stamp Review Maybelline Colossal Bold Eyeliner Review: Black... Maybelline Colossal Bold Eyeliner Review: Black... Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner Review: Bold B... Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner Review: Bold B...