CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

NYX I Know That's Bright Eyeshadow Palette Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Ultimate Shadow Palette - I Know That's Bright is a 16-pan colour palette for vivid eye and face makeup looks. It scores strongly for visible colour result, blendability, application and value, with many reviews praising its bright shades and solid wear. Its key limitation is that some pans are designated for face use rather than the eye area.
Expert reviewed
85
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Ultimate Shadow Palette in I Know That's Bright is a compact 16-pan makeup palette built around high-impact colour. The supplied product information describes vegan pigments and a range of matte, satin, shimmery and metallic finishes, giving users options for layered, graphic or statement-led looks. It is positioned as a professional-level palette, with NYX suggesting primer for bolder, longer-lasting colour. Based on the colour story and review feedback, it appears best suited to shoppers who want bright shades rather than a primarily neutral everyday edit. The palette has a 4.5/5 average from 26,340 ratings, and reviewers often mention smooth blending, vibrant payoff and good value. A crucial practical detail is that some colours are labelled for face use, so the palette should not be assumed to contain 16 eye-area shades.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Number of Items
1
Age Range Description
Adult
Package Type Name
Box
Manufacturer
NYX Professional Makeup
UPC
800897245481
Item Type Name
Eyeshadow
Container Type
Palette

Product details

Product Dimensions
0.71 x 3.9 x 3.78 inches; 3.82 ounces
UPC
800897245481
Manufacturer
NYX Professional Makeup

Scores breakdown

84 /100

Effectiveness

88 /100

Beauty results

40 /100

Skin compatibility

82 /100

Shade range

85 /100

Finish quality

82 /100

Longevity

78 /100

Ingredient quality

42 /100

Safety

Strengths

  • Vibrant 16-pan colour story designed for bold makeup looks.
  • High application score of 88/100 reflects reported smooth, blendable performance.
  • Mixed matte, satin, shimmery and metallic finishes support varied eye looks.
  • Strong value score of 91/100 at the listed price of $16.25.
  • Large review base of 26,340 ratings and a 4.5/5 average.
  • Vegan and cruelty-free status is stated in the product information.
  • Packaging is stated to contain 30% recycled material.

Limitations

  • Some palette colours are labelled for face use rather than the eye area, despite the eyeshadow-palette positioning.
  • Reviewers describe this disclosure as easy to miss on the packaging.
  • Pigmentation feedback is mixed, even though many buyers praise the colour payoff.
  • Packaging quality is moderate at 74/100; one review reported a shattered pan on arrival.
  • Wear claims are partly difficult to isolate when reviewers use primer or setting spray.
  • The bright colour selection may be less practical for shoppers seeking a neutral everyday palette.

Ideal user profiles

  • Makeup users who want vivid, buildable colour for creative eye and face looks.
  • Buyers seeking a lower-cost palette with multiple finishes.
  • Users comfortable checking individual pan labels before applying colour around the eyes.
  • People who prefer vegan, cruelty-free makeup based on the supplied product information.
  • Occasion makeup users creating costume, festival or statement looks.

Use cases

  • Bright, expressive eye makeup looks using shades designated for the eye area.
  • Colourful face makeup with pans labelled for face use.
  • Costume, themed-event and creative makeup.
  • Building layered looks with matte, satin, shimmer and metallic finishes.
  • Adding a bold accent colour to an otherwise simple makeup routine.
  • Creating looks with primer for potentially more intense or longer-lasting colour.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This is primarily a makeup product, positioned as a colourful powder palette for eye makeup and, for selected shades, face makeup. Its role is to add colour, dimension and finish variety to a completed makeup look, rather than replace complexion or base products. The mixed finishes make it relevant for simple colour accents as well as more layered creative looks. Because some pans are not intended for the eye area, users should treat it as a mixed-use colour palette and follow each pan’s stated directions.

Best for

This palette is best for makeup users who enjoy saturated brights, buildable colour and experimenting with different finishes. Its 88/100 beauty-result and application scores, plus frequent reports of smooth blending, make it a practical option for creative looks at a listed price of $16.25. It also suits buyers seeking products described as vegan and cruelty-free. It is most appropriate for users who will check the intended-use labelling before choosing shades for the eye area.

Not best for

It is not the clearest choice for shoppers who expect every pan in an eyeshadow palette to be designed for use around the eyes. Reviews specifically flag that some shades are for face use, and the disclosure was not obvious to several buyers. Those wanting muted neutrals, consistently verified pigmentation across every shade, or especially robust delivery protection may prefer a palette better aligned with those priorities.

Beauty results

The visible result is colourful, high-impact makeup with options ranging from matte depth to satin, shimmer and metallic reflect. The 88/100 beauty-result score is consistent with reviews praising vivid shades, flattering colour and buildable payoff. Results will depend on shade selection and application method, particularly where primer is used.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 84/100, this palette appears to perform well at its central task: delivering colourful makeup that can be blended and built into a look. Buyers frequently praise the vivid shades, smooth application and staying power, while the product listing describes a 16-pan mix of finishes. Performance is not entirely uniform, however, as pigmentation feedback is mixed. The most important functional limitation is not colour performance but use classification: some shades are intended for face use rather than the eye area.

Beauty results

The beauty-result score of 88/100 reflects the palette’s strongest feature: an expressive, colourful finish. Reviewers describe the colours as gorgeous, bright and capable of creating varied looks, while one buyer found the pigmentation intense enough to tone down. Matte, satin, shimmer and metallic options should help users vary depth and reflect. Results remain shade- and technique-dependent, and only appropriately designated colours should be used on the eyes.

Skin compatibility

Skin compatibility scores 40/100, largely because the supplied information raises an important intended-use concern rather than providing broad sensitive-skin suitability evidence. Multiple reviewers state that some pans are not for the eye area. No detailed ingredient list or sensitivity testing information is provided here. Follow the product labelling closely, avoid using face-designated shades around the eyes, and stop use if discomfort occurs.

Shade range

The shade-range score is 82/100. This 16-pan palette offers a bright, creative colour direction and a mix of finishes, which gives it meaningful flexibility for statement makeup. Reviews indicate that buyers can create different styles with the shades, though the selection is less suited to someone seeking a neutral-only palette. Most importantly, range should be assessed by intended use as well as colour: not all pans are labelled for the eye area.

How it compares

Within the bright eyeshadow-palette category, this product appears more competitive for value, blendability and visible colour impact than for universally simple eye-area use. Its 16-pan format and varied finishes make it versatile for creative makeup, while the 91/100 value score is notably strong at the listed price. It also has substantial buyer feedback, with high satisfaction overall. In comparison with a palette designed solely for eye use, however, it requires more careful shade selection because some pans are face-designated. Its packaging and physical durability scores are solid but not category-leading.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 85/100, NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette - I Know That's Bright ranks as a strong value-led option in the colourful makeup palette category. It performs especially well for value (91/100), beauty result (88/100), application (88/100), customer satisfaction (87/100) and ease of use (86/100). Reviews reinforce the appeal of vivid colour, smooth blending and flexible finishes. Its ranking is held back by low safety and skin-compatibility scores, which reflect a meaningful disclosure issue: some pans are intended for face use rather than the eye area. Packaging and physical durability are also more moderate than its colour performance.

Buying advice

Consider this palette if you want vivid, buildable colour, several finishes and a lower-priced option for creative makeup. It is particularly relevant for occasion looks, costumes and bold colour accents, and reviewers generally find it easy to blend. Before buying, examine the product’s shade-use labelling carefully: some pans are intended for face use rather than the eye area. If you want an all-eye-shadow palette, muted everyday tones or clearer usage separation, this may not be the best fit. On delivery, inspect the pans promptly because one supplied review reported breakage in transit.
85
Overall score

Final verdict

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Ultimate Shadow Palette - I Know That's Bright is a strong colourful makeup option with an overall score of 85/100. Its main strengths are vivid visual payoff, smooth and buildable application, varied finishes and excellent value at the listed price. Broad customer feedback is positive, particularly on colour and blending. Its central limitation is important: some shades are not intended for use around the eyes, and reviewers found that detail easy to miss. It is best viewed as a mixed-use bright colour palette for informed users who will follow the individual shade directions.
Back to review

Key topics

NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette I Know That's Bright review, NYX I Know That's Bright eyeshadow palette, bright eyeshadow palette review, vegan eyeshadow palette, NYX colourful makeup palette, cruelty-free eyeshadow palette, pigmented eyeshadow palette, 16 pan eyeshadow palette

Frequently asked questions

Is the NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette I Know That's Bright good for bold makeup looks?
It appears well suited to bold, colourful makeup looks. The palette includes 16 pigmented shades and a mix of matte, satin, shimmer and metallic finishes. Its beauty-result score is 88/100, while reviews frequently mention vibrant colour and blendability. Check each pan’s intended use before applying it around the eyes.
Can every shade in the I Know That's Bright palette be used as eyeshadow?
No. Supplied reviews repeatedly state that some colours are designated for face use rather than the eye area. Several buyers found this disclosure easy to overlook because the product is presented as an eyeshadow palette. Review the on-pack labelling for each shade and use colours only as directed.
How pigmented is the NYX I Know That's Bright palette?
The evidence is mixed. Many reviewers describe the colours as vibrant, highly pigmented and buildable, while the aggregated review overview notes that some buyers expected stronger pigmentation. The product information claims true-to-pan payoff, but that is a brand claim rather than independently verified evidence. Primer may affect the intensity achieved.
Does the NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette last all day?
Its longevity score is 82/100, and the aggregated review overview says many customers find the colours hold up well without fading or smudging. However, wear can vary by shade, skin conditions and application method. One reviewer also noted that they use primer and setting spray, making standalone wear harder to assess.
Is this NYX palette easy to blend and apply?
It scores 86/100 for ease of use and 88/100 for application. Reviews commonly describe the powders as smooth and easy to blend, with one buyer reporting no clumping during wear. The compact palette format also keeps the shades together for look-building, although users should identify eye-safe pans before application.
Is the NYX I Know That's Bright palette good value?
At the listed price of $16.25, the palette earns a value score of 91/100. It offers 16 pans, varied finishes and a bright colour selection, while many reviewers consider the performance strong for the price. Value is less compelling if you expected every colour to be suitable for eye-area use.
Is the NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette suitable for sensitive eyes?
The available information does not establish suitability for sensitive eyes, and the skin-compatibility score is 40/100. More importantly, some shades are not intended for use around the eyes. Follow the product’s usage directions, avoid using face-designated colours in the eye area, and discontinue use if discomfort occurs.
What are the main drawbacks of the I Know That's Bright palette?
The main concern is clarity: reviewers repeatedly note that some bright pans are for face use, not the eye area. Pigmentation feedback also varies between buyers, and one supplied review reported a shattered shade on delivery. These issues temper otherwise strong scores for colour result, application, customer satisfaction and value.

Related Guides & Rankings

Covergirl Eye Enhancers Natural Nudes Eyeshadow... Covergirl Eye Enhancers Natural Nudes Eyeshadow... Revlon ColorStay Moonlit Eyeshadow Palette Review Revlon ColorStay Moonlit Eyeshadow Palette Review BestLand 12-Color Nude Eyeshadow Palette Review BestLand 12-Color Nude Eyeshadow Palette Review BOLOPER Color E Smokey Eyeshadow Palette Review BOLOPER Color E Smokey Eyeshadow Palette Review