CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

Revlon ColorStay Day to Night Eyeshadow Palette Review

The Revlon ColorStay Day to Night Eyeshadow Palette in 555 Moonlit is an affordable four-shade powder eye palette with matte and shimmer finishes for soft daytime or more defined evening looks. It scores well for value, longevity, blending, and customer satisfaction, although pigmentation and powder fallout receive mixed feedback.
Expert reviewed
79
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

Revlon ColorStay Day to Night in 555 Moonlit is a compact 0.16 oz powder eyeshadow palette designed for adult makeup users. The product description presents it as a powder-cream hybrid formula: it applies like powder, aims to wear like cream, and is described as buttery soft. Its coordinated shades are intended to move from subtle daytime makeup to more dramatic evening looks, with matte and shimmer finishes in the range. At $7.97, Moonlit sits in the accessible makeup segment and has substantial buyer feedback, with 18,757 reviews and a 4.4/5 average rating. Reviewers frequently praise its smooth feel, blendability, and wear. Still, results are not entirely uniform: some customers find the colour payoff strong, while others report softer-than-expected pigment, crumbliness, or fallout.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Item details

Brand Name
REVLON
Number of Items
1
Age Range Description
Adult
Manufacturer
Revlon
UPC
309978535126
Global Trade Identification Number
00309978535126
Manufacturer Part Number
52170120
Model Number
309978535126
Country as Labeled
United States
Container Type
Palette

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
2.56 x 0.51 x 2.56 inches; 1.41 ounces
Item model number
309978535126
UPC
309978535126
Manufacturer
Revlon

Scores breakdown

82 /100

Effectiveness

81 /100

Beauty results

77 /100

Skin compatibility

70 /100

Shade range

81 /100

Finish quality

84 /100

Longevity

62 /100

Ingredient quality

77 /100

Safety

Strengths

  • Affordable $7.97 price with a strong 87/100 value score.
  • Buttery-feeling powder-cream hybrid formula is described as easy to blend.
  • Moonlit offers coordinated neutral shades for day-to-evening eye looks.
  • Longevity is a relative strength at 84/100, with several reviewers reporting all-day wear.
  • High buyer satisfaction: 4.4/5 stars across 18,757 reviews and an 86/100 satisfaction score.
  • Matte and shimmer finishes add variety within the compact palette.

Limitations

  • Pigmentation feedback is mixed; some buyers find the shades less vibrant than expected.
  • Some reviews mention crumbliness, fallout, and dust mixing between compartments.
  • The individual Moonlit palette has limited shade customisation, reflected in its 70/100 shade-range score.
  • Not every shade is matte; one reviewer specifically noted unexpected shine.
  • Ingredient quality and transparency are comparatively limited at 62/100 because a full ingredient list was not provided.
  • Packaging durability is a potential concern, with one review describing a damaged lid.

Ideal user profiles

  • Everyday makeup users seeking a compact neutral eye palette.
  • Buyers who want matte and shimmer options in one affordable palette.
  • People who prefer soft, buildable day-to-night eye looks.
  • Users comfortable working with powder shadow and managing minor fallout if it occurs.

Use cases

  • Quick neutral eye makeup for everyday routines.
  • Building a soft daytime eye look.
  • Adding shimmer or depth for evening makeup.
  • Travel or handbag makeup kits that need a small palette format.
  • Budget-conscious makeup shopping.
  • Layered eye looks using coordinated shades from a single quad.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This is a makeup product, specifically a compact powder eyeshadow quad for creating coordinated eye looks. Its role is to provide a small edit of compatible shades rather than the broad choice of a larger palette. Moonlit is positioned for flexible everyday-to-evening use, combining matte and shimmer effects in a portable palette. The formula and review profile make it most relevant to users who value simple application, blendability, and accessible pricing over extensive shade customisation.

Best for

Moonlit is best for budget-conscious makeup users looking for a compact neutral palette that can handle routine day-to-night eye looks. Its 82/100 application and effectiveness scores, 84/100 longevity score, and 87/100 value score align with reviews praising smooth blending and all-day wear. It may especially appeal to users who like a mix of matte and shimmer rather than a fully matte eye wardrobe.

Not best for

This palette may not be the best match for shoppers who need highly saturated colour from every shade, a large range of tones, or a completely matte finish. Pigmentation is inconsistent across the available feedback, and some users report crumbling or powder dust between compartments. Those with ingredient sensitivities should also check the on-pack ingredient information, as a complete ingredient list was not supplied here.

Beauty results

Moonlit is designed to create soft, coordinated eye makeup that can be built into a more defined evening look. The 81/100 beauty-result score reflects generally attractive colour and finish results, with reviews noting pretty colours and a silky effect. The mix of matte and shimmer provides visual variation, though colour intensity may appear less vivid than expected for some users.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

The palette earns an 82/100 effectiveness score, indicating solid performance for its core purpose: adding blendable eye colour in an affordable compact format. Reviews repeatedly mention easy application, smooth texture, and wear through the day, which aligns with the product's day-to-night positioning. However, effectiveness is moderated by mixed reports on pigment strength and powder performance. Some users find the shades rich, whereas others report less vibrancy, crumbliness, or fallout. It appears most dependable for soft, buildable looks rather than guaranteed high-impact colour.

Beauty results

With an 81/100 beauty-result score, Moonlit appears capable of producing polished, wearable eye looks with matte and shimmer contrast. Reviews describe the colours as pretty and coordinated, while the brand positions the palette for both subtle and more dramatic styling. The main qualification is payoff consistency: the finished look may be softer than product imagery suggests for some users, especially if they prefer bold colour.

Skin compatibility

The 77/100 skin-compatibility score suggests a generally moderate profile for an eye-area makeup product, not a universal suitability guarantee. One reviewer reported no allergic reaction, but that single experience should not be treated as evidence for all users. Since the supplied data does not include a complete ingredient list, people with known sensitivities should inspect the packaging information and discontinue use if discomfort occurs.

Shade range

Shade range scores 70/100, reflecting the limits of a four-pan palette rather than a broad colour wardrobe. Moonlit provides coordinated options for a contained eye look, and reviews describe the colours as suitable for neutral everyday use. However, there is limited room for customising depth, undertone, or finish within this individual palette. One review also notes the absence of a dark shade, which may matter for users who prefer stronger definition.

How it compares

Within the affordable powder-eyeshadow category, Moonlit appears stronger for value, routine usability, blendability, and everyday wear than for extensive customisation or consistently high-impact pigment. Its 87/100 value score and 86/100 customer-satisfaction score are especially favourable, while its 84/100 longevity score supports its day-to-night positioning. The palette's mixed matte and shimmer finishes add versatility, but the four-shade selection is inherently narrower than larger palettes. Buyers who prioritise ingredient disclosure, highly vivid payoff, or exceptionally robust packaging may find its 62/100 ingredient-quality and 72/100 packaging scores less competitive.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 79/100, Revlon ColorStay Day to Night Moonlit ranks as a strong affordable eyeshadow-palette option rather than a category leader in every area. Its best results come from value (87/100), customer satisfaction (86/100), longevity (84/100), and application (82/100). The compact format, blendable texture, and versatile matte-and-shimmer combination support its everyday appeal. Its ranking is held back by modest ingredient-quality transparency (62/100), a limited individual shade selection (70/100), moderate packaging and durability scores, and mixed reports of pigment strength and fallout.

Buying advice

Consider Revlon Moonlit if you want a low-cost, compact eye palette for neutral-looking everyday makeup and occasional evening definition. Its review profile supports smooth blending, comfortable texture, and generally good wear, while the $7.97 price strengthens its appeal. Before buying, check that the Moonlit colour story and mixed matte-shimmer finish match your preferences; it is not an all-matte quad and may not supply a deep enough shade for every look. If you have ingredient sensitivities, consult the product packaging for the full formula. Handle the palette carefully if fallout or fragile packaging is a concern.
79
Overall score

Final verdict

Revlon ColorStay Day to Night 555 Moonlit is a strong budget option for users who want a compact, blendable eyeshadow palette for day-to-evening makeup. Its main strengths are value, positive customer satisfaction, smooth application, and generally favourable wear. The principal limitation is inconsistency: some users report satisfying pigment and lasting colour, while others find the shades less vivid or the formula crumbly. With an overall 79/100 score, it is best considered a practical everyday quad rather than a high-pigment or highly customisable palette. Check the finish mix and full ingredient information before purchasing.
Back to review

Key topics

Revlon ColorStay Day to Night eyeshadow palette, Revlon Moonlit 555 review, Revlon eyeshadow palette review, affordable neutral eyeshadow palette, matte shimmer eyeshadow quad, longwear powder eyeshadow, blendable eyeshadow palette

Frequently asked questions

Is the Revlon ColorStay Day to Night Moonlit palette good for everyday makeup?
Based on its 81/100 beauty-result score, 82/100 application score, and reviewer feedback, Moonlit appears well suited to everyday eye makeup. The palette is positioned around coordinated transitional shades for subtle-to-more-defined looks. Its compact quad format is convenient, although users wanting many colour choices may find it restrictive.
How pigmented is the Revlon Moonlit 555 eyeshadow palette?
Pigmentation receives mixed feedback. Some reviewers describe rich or decent colour payoff, while others say the colours are less vibrant than pictured or not especially pigmented. The product description states that shades are full pigment and buildable, but individual results may depend on shade choice, application method, and preferred intensity.
Does Revlon ColorStay Day to Night eyeshadow last all day?
Longevity is one of the stronger areas, with an 84/100 score. The listing states up to 24-hour wear, while several reviews report all-day wear and one mentions no creasing. These customer experiences support generally positive wear feedback, but they do not independently verify a 24-hour result for every user.
Does the Moonlit palette have matte or shimmer shades?
The palette is sold with matte and shimmer finishes. Review feedback also indicates that the Moonlit quad includes matte shades alongside a satin or shimmery shade. If you want an entirely matte palette, check the shade layout before buying, as one customer expected matte shadows and found that the palette included shine.
Is the Revlon Moonlit eyeshadow easy to blend?
The blendability profile is positive overall, supported by an 82/100 application score and an 80/100 ease-of-use score. Reviews commonly mention smooth application, a silky texture, and easy blending. However, some users report flaking or a crumbly texture, so applying gradually may help reduce powder fallout.
Is Revlon ColorStay Day to Night Moonlit good value?
At the provided price of $7.97, the palette earns an 87/100 value score. Its affordable price, strong review volume, 4.4/5 average rating, and generally favourable comments on wear and blending support its value position. It is less compelling for shoppers who prioritise consistently intense pigmentation or broad shade selection.
Is the Revlon Moonlit palette suitable for sensitive eyes or skin?
The skin-compatibility and safety scores are both 77/100, indicating a moderate rather than exceptional profile. One reviewer reported no allergic reaction, but an individual review cannot establish broad suitability. A complete ingredient list was not provided, so people with known sensitivities should review the package information and use appropriate caution around the eye area.
What are the main drawbacks of the Revlon Moonlit 555 palette?
The main drawbacks are mixed pigmentation feedback, reports of fallout or powder dust in the compartments, and a limited four-shade selection within this specific palette. Packaging scores are also moderate at 72/100, with one review reporting a damaged lid. Ingredient transparency is limited in the supplied product information.

Related Guides & Rankings

BestLand 12-Color Nude Eyeshadow Palette Review BestLand 12-Color Nude Eyeshadow Palette Review BOLOPER Color E Smokey Eyeshadow Palette Review BOLOPER Color E Smokey Eyeshadow Palette Review e.l.f. Berry Bad Bite-Size Eyeshadow Palette Re... e.l.f. Berry Bad Bite-Size Eyeshadow Palette Re...