Review

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in Sugar Glass is a clear lip gloss designed to add shine with a soft, creamy feel. It stands out for comfort, finish and value, making it a practical everyday makeup option. Its main limitation is wear time, as longevity feedback is mixed and reapplication may be needed.

Expert reviewed

Overall score

Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 1

Our verdict

Quick take

This scoring profile points to a lip gloss that performs best in comfort, finish, value and buyer satisfaction. It looks especially strong for users who want shine and a soft feel at a low price. The weaker areas are longevity, packaging and ingredient transparency, so it is less convincing for shoppers who want long wear or detailed formulation information.

Best for

Beauty & Personal Care Makeup Lips Lip Glosses

Released: 29 May 2026

Why we ranked it highly

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss is a liquid lip gloss in a tube format with a glossy finish and sheer-to-medium coverage. This listing is for Sugar Glass, a clear shade designed for users who want shine without strong colour, or who prefer to layer gloss over other lip products. Based on the provided description and review summary, the formula is positioned as buttery, smooth and non-sticky, with a softening feel on the lips. Within a makeup routine, this product fits as an easy finishing step for a polished lip look. It appears especially suited to everyday wear, quick touch-ups and shoppers looking for a lower-cost gloss from a widely available brand. Reviews suggest comfort and appearance are major strengths, while staying power is less consistent, particularly through eating and drinking.

90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Item Form: Liquid
Finish Types: Glossy
Product Benefits: Softening,Smoothening,Makeup
Specialty: Cruelty Free,Long Lasting
Skin Tone: All
Container Type: Tube
Package Type Name: Tube
Lip Color Type: Lip Gloss
Lip Color Undertone: Neutral
Lip Color Shade Depth: Light
Lip Color Intensity: Sheer
Skin Type: All
Coverage: Sheer-to-medium

Item details

Brand Name: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Color: 54 Sugar Glass
Age Range Description: Adult
Target Audience: Unisex-Adults
Package Type Name: Tube
Manufacturer: NYX Professional Makeup
UPC: 800897226596
Global Trade Identification Number: 00800897226596
Set Name: Butter Gloss
Manufacturer Part Number: 800897226596
Model Number: 800897226596

Product details

Language: English
Product Dimensions: 0.39 x 0.27 x 1.41 inches; 0.04 ounces
Item model number: 800897226596
UPC: 800897226596
Manufacturer: NYX Professional Makeup

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 2

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 3

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 4

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 5

Scores breakdown

88 /100

Effectiveness

90 /100

Beauty results

85 /100

Skin compatibility

88 /100

Shade range

91 /100

Finish quality

72 /100

Longevity

58 /100

Ingredient quality

82 /100

Safety

Strengths

Very strong comfort profile, with many reviewers describing the formula as smooth, creamy and mostly non-sticky.
Glossy finish stands out, supported by a high finish quality score and repeated praise for natural shine.
Excellent value for money based on the low price point, large review base and strong satisfaction scores.
Wide shade range within the Butter Gloss line adds flexibility for different looks, even though this listing is for the clear Sugar Glass shade.
Easy tube format supports quick application and touch-ups.
Cruelty-free positioning is clearly stated and supported by the brand information provided.

Limitations

Longevity is the clearest weakness, with mixed feedback on how long the gloss lasts and regular reapplication often needed after eating or drinking.
Transfer resistance does not appear to be a strong point, which is typical for gloss textures and mentioned in reviews.
Ingredient quality assessment is limited by the lack of a full ingredient list in the provided data.
Some users note slight stickiness at first application, even though many still find it comfortable overall.
Packaging quality appears functional rather than standout, with a mid-range score and limited detail on applicator performance.
Shade appearance can vary on the lips versus listing images, based on user feedback from other shades in the range.

Ideal user profiles

Anyone looking for an affordable everyday lip gloss with a glossy, comfortable finish.
Users who dislike heavy or very sticky lip products.
Shoppers who want a clear gloss that can be worn alone or layered over other lip colours.
Buyers who prioritise value and strong customer feedback over long wear.
Users interested in cruelty-free makeup options from a well-known mass-market brand.

Use cases

Adding a clear glossy finish to bare lips.
Layering over lipstick or lip liner for extra shine.
Everyday makeup routines that need a quick, low-effort lip product.
Touch-ups during the day when comfort matters more than all-day wear.
Creating a softer, less opaque lip look with sheer shine.
Custom lip looks using the clear gloss with other colours.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This product sits firmly in the makeup category as a lip gloss. Its main role is to add shine, a smoother-looking lip finish and a light, comfortable feel rather than provide full coverage or long-wear colour. Sugar Glass, as a clear gloss, is particularly versatile in a routine because it can be worn alone, layered over lipstick or lip liner, or used to adjust the finish of other lip products.

Best for

NYX Butter Gloss in Sugar Glass is best for users who want an affordable lip gloss with a glossy finish, comfortable texture and flexible everyday use. It suits people who prefer lighter lip products, want a clear topper for lipstick, or need a simple gloss for casual makeup looks. Strong comfort, value and customer satisfaction scores make it especially appealing for budget-conscious shoppers.

Not best for

This gloss may not be the best fit for buyers who want strong transfer resistance or long wear with minimal touch-ups. It is also less ideal for shoppers who need ingredient transparency, since a full ingredient breakdown was not provided here. Users who strongly dislike any initial tackiness may want to note that some reviews mention slight stickiness at first application.

Beauty results

The main beauty result is a smooth, glossy lip look with a soft, cushioned appearance. In the clear Sugar Glass shade, the finish adds shine and helps lips look more polished without obvious colour, making it useful both alone and as a layering product.

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 6

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 88 , NYX Butter Gloss appears to perform well at its core purpose: delivering shine, a smooth lip feel and easy everyday wear. The provided description and customer feedback strongly support the formula’s soft, creamy texture and glossy payoff. For Sugar Glass specifically, effectiveness is tied more to finish and versatility than colour impact. The main performance concern is longevity, since multiple reviewers note fading with eating or drinking. Overall, it looks effective as a comfortable gloss, but less reliable as a long-wear lip product.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 90 reflects a strong cosmetic payoff for this type of product. Reviews repeatedly describe a natural, flattering shine and a smooth lip appearance. In the clear Sugar Glass shade, the result is less about pigment and more about enhancing the lips with gloss, softness and a polished finish that layers easily with other makeup.

Skin compatibility

With a skin compatibility score of 85 , this lip gloss appears broadly suitable for general use, especially since it is described for all skin types and many users report a comfortable feel. However, the provided data does not include a full ingredient list or specific testing information for sensitive users. If fragrance or certain cosmetic ingredients are a concern, extra caution is reasonable.

Shade range

The shade range score of 88 suggests the wider Butter Gloss line offers strong flexibility. The product details mention a wide variety of shades, and user reviews reference different tones from nude to mauve to brown. For this listing, Sugar Glass is clear, which makes it one of the most adaptable options because it can suit different lip looks without requiring an exact shade match.

Finish quality

With a finish quality score of 91 , this is one of the product’s standout areas. The finish is described as glossy, and review feedback consistently supports a smooth, creamy shine rather than a heavy or greasy look. For a clear gloss, finish quality matters more than pigment, and Sugar Glass appears to deliver a polished, flattering result that works well alone or layered.

Longevity

The longevity score of 72 is one of the weaker parts of the overall profile. Reviews are mixed: some users say it lasts for hours or better than expected for a gloss, while others note that it fades fairly quickly, especially after eating or drinking. That makes it more suitable for users who do not mind reapplying than for those seeking all-day wear.

Ingredient quality

The ingredient quality score of 58 is modest, largely because the provided data does not include a full ingredient list or detailed formulation transparency. There are positive signs around texture and user comfort, and the brand does state cruelty-free positioning, but that is not the same as ingredient quality evidence. Without fuller ingredient disclosure here, it is difficult to assess the presence or absence of fragrance, common irritants or ingredient-specific benefits in a detailed way.

Safety

With a safety score of 82 , this lip gloss appears generally low risk for standard cosmetic use based on the information provided. It is intended for lips, has broad positive customer feedback and no specific safety issue is repeatedly flagged in the supplied reviews. Still, as with any lip product, users with sensitivities should check the ingredient list before buying if available elsewhere, especially because full ingredient details were not included in this dataset.

Comfort

The comfort score of 93 is a major strength. Reviewers repeatedly describe the gloss as buttery, smooth, lightweight and comfortable, with many specifically praising the non-sticky feel. A small number mention slight tackiness at first, but overall the user experience appears highly positive, especially for a gloss in this price range.

Ease of use

With an ease of use score of 90 , Butter Gloss looks simple to fit into a routine. The tube packaging, straightforward gloss format and easy layering potential all support convenient use. Sugar Glass is especially low effort because the clear finish removes the need for precise shade matching, though reapplication through the day can add a little routine friction.

Application

The application score of 88 suggests the gloss generally goes on smoothly and evenly. Reviews often describe the texture as creamy and easy to spread, though some note it can feel thicker at first before settling. For Sugar Glass, application is helped by the clear shade, since it is more forgiving than pigmented glosses and works well for quick touch-ups.

Scent

The scent score of 80 points to a generally positive but not universally defining scent experience. Some reviewers say it smells amazing, which adds to the overall appeal, but the provided data does not give detailed fragrance information. Users sensitive to scented lip products may still want to check ingredients before buying.

Packaging quality

The packaging quality score of 76 suggests functional packaging rather than a standout presentation. The tube format is practical for gloss and easy to carry, but there is limited detail in the provided data about applicator precision, leakage resistance or long-term packaging performance. It appears serviceable, though not a major differentiator.

Personalization

With a personalization score of 90 , the Butter Gloss range offers strong flexibility. The line is described as available in many shades, and Sugar Glass adds another level of versatility because it is clear and easy to layer. That makes it suitable for users who want to customise their lip look without committing to a single strong pigment or finish.

Durability

The durability score of 74 is moderate. For a consumable gloss, this is less about hardware and more about how well the product remains usable and how stable the packaging feels over time. The key weakness appears to be wear durability on the lips rather than major product failure, though the mid-range packaging score suggests average long-term robustness overall.

Value analysis

With a value score of 95 , this is one of the product’s clearest strengths. At a price of 5.97, Butter Gloss sits in an accessible part of the market while still earning a 4.5-star average from more than 123,000 reviews. Reviewers frequently say it performs better than pricier alternatives, particularly in comfort and finish. The need for reapplication does reduce value slightly for users who prioritise long wear, but for shoppers focused on affordable gloss, soft texture and overall satisfaction, the product appears to deliver very strong return for the price.

Brand trust

The brand trust score of 84 suggests solid confidence in NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP as a mainstream makeup brand. The brand is clearly positioned within colour cosmetics and provides a broad lip range, which supports category credibility. The cruelty-free statement also adds transparency, though this does not fully replace ingredient-level detail or product-specific evidence.

Customer satisfaction

The customer satisfaction score of 95 is strongly supported by the available data. The product has a 4.5/5 star rating from 123,926 reviews , which is a substantial review base. Repeated praise centres on texture, comfort, shine, shade appeal and price-to-performance. The most common complaint is longevity, with multiple users noting that reapplication is needed after meals or drinks. Even so, repurchase intent appears strong in the reviews provided, which reinforces the very high satisfaction profile.

Claim support

With a claim support score of 86 , the main product claims are fairly well supported by the provided information. The description highlights a buttery, smooth, non-sticky feel and sheer-to-medium glossy coverage, and these points align well with the review overview and individual customer comments. The weaker area is the “long lasting” specialty claim, which is only partly supported because wear time feedback is mixed. Overall, comfort and finish claims appear more consistently backed than longevity claims.

Ethical transparency

The ethical transparency score of 92 is strong because the provided data includes a clear cruelty-free statement and says the brand is acknowledged by PETA as cruelty free. That gives this aspect more support than many beauty listings provide. No further sustainability or ingredient sourcing claims were included here, so the analysis should remain limited to cruelty-free transparency.

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 7

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 8

NYX Butter Gloss Sugar Glass Review: Clear Lip Gloss image 9

How it compares

Within the lip gloss category, NYX Butter Gloss appears stronger than many alternatives on comfort and value. Its high finish score suggests it competes well on visible gloss payoff, while the very high customer satisfaction score shows broad buyer approval across a very large review base. Compared with many glosses, its non-sticky feel seems to be a real advantage. Where it looks more average is wear time, since it does not consistently solve the common gloss problem of fading with meals or drinks. Overall, it appears best positioned as a dependable, affordable gloss rather than a premium long-wear formula.

Ranking summary

NYX Butter Gloss ranks highly on the strength of its overall 89 score, with especially impressive results in comfort, finish, value, customer satisfaction and ease of use. It stands out as a practical, affordable lip gloss that consistently delivers a glossy, smooth-looking result without the heavy stickiness some users expect from gloss formulas. The huge review count and strong average rating also reinforce its position as a widely trusted option in the category. Its main reason for not ranking even higher is longevity: while some users report good wear for a gloss, many still mention the need to reapply after eating or drinking.

Buying advice

Consider this product if you want an affordable gloss that feels comfortable, looks glossy and works easily in an everyday makeup routine. Sugar Glass is particularly useful if you want a clear topper for lipstick or a simple shine-only option. If long wear is your top priority, this may be less suitable, because customer feedback on staying power is mixed. Before buying, think about whether you are comfortable reapplying during the day, and if you are sensitive to scented lip products or specific ingredients, check the ingredient list from the retailer or brand source first.

Overall score

Final verdict

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in Sugar Glass is a strong option in the affordable lip gloss category. Its biggest strengths are comfort, glossy finish and excellent value, backed by a very large volume of positive customer feedback. The clear shade also adds versatility, making it easy to wear alone or layer over other lip products. Its main limitation is longevity, which appears less consistent than the comfort and finish performance. For shoppers who want a low-cost, easy-to-use gloss and do not mind occasional touch-ups, it is one of the more convincing mass-market choices.

Back to review

Key topics

nyx professional makeup butter gloss review, nyx butter gloss sugar glass, clear lip gloss review, non sticky lip gloss, drugstore lip gloss, glossy lip makeup, sheer to medium lip gloss, cruelty free lip gloss, affordable lip gloss, nyx lip gloss review

Frequently asked questions

Is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in Sugar Glass a good everyday lip gloss?

Yes, it appears well suited to everyday use. The provided data and reviews consistently highlight a smooth, glossy finish, comfortable wear and strong value. Its main trade-off is wear time, since several users say it needs reapplication after eating or drinking.

Does NYX Butter Gloss feel sticky on the lips?

Most of the review feedback describes the formula as non-sticky or far less sticky than many glosses. A few users mention slight stickiness at first application, but the broader pattern suggests it settles into a smoother, more comfortable feel after a short time.

How long does NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss last?

Longevity looks mixed rather than exceptional. Some reviewers say it lasts a few hours or longer than expected for a gloss, while others note that it fades sooner, especially with eating or drinking. Based on the longevity score, touch-ups are likely part of the experience.

Is Sugar Glass a clear lip gloss?

Yes. This listing is for the shade 54 Sugar Glass, which is a clear gloss option. Based on review feedback, it works well on its own for shine and can also be layered with lipstick or other lip colours for a customised finish.

Who is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss best for?

It is best for users who want a comfortable, glossy lip product at a low price. It especially suits shoppers who prefer a softer, non-heavy feel and do not mind reapplying through the day. The clear shade also makes it practical for layering.

Does NYX Butter Gloss offer good value for money?

Yes, value is one of its strongest areas. The product is low priced, has a very large review count and holds a strong average rating. Many reviewers directly compare it favourably with more expensive glosses, which supports the high value score.

Are the claims around comfort and finish well supported?

Mostly yes. The provided information says the gloss is soft, smooth and non-sticky, and review feedback broadly supports those points. Claims around long-lasting wear are less consistently supported, as customer feedback on longevity is clearly mixed.

Is NYX Butter Gloss suitable for sensitive lips?

The product has a solid skin compatibility score, but the provided data does not include a full ingredient list or specific sensitive-skin testing details. If you are highly reactive to lip products, checking ingredients and doing a cautious patch test would be the safer approach.

Related Guides & Rankings

Burt's Bees Original Beeswax Lip Balm Review

NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil Review: Always Onyx E...

wet n wild Silk Finish Lipstick Review: Dark Pi...

NYX HD Studio Photogenic Concealer Wand Review