NYX Butter Gloss vs NYX Lip IV Hydrating Glossy Lip Stain

Both products score well for safety (Butter Gloss 82; Lip IV 79) and are typical leave-on lip cosmetics. The most practical safety considerations are routine ones for lip products: avoid use on broken or irritated skin, stop use if discomfort occurs, and keep the applicator hygienic (especially if you’re reapplying throughout the day). Lip IV includes mentions of a coconut-like scent/taste in reviews, which may be relevant if you’re sensitive to flavored or scented lip products.

Because detailed ingredient lists aren’t provided here, users with known sensitivities should verify ingredients before purchase.

NYX Butter Gloss wins on comfort (93 vs 88). Review themes strongly emphasize a creamy texture that “melts” and feels non-sticky after it settles, making it easy to wear for long stretches even if you need to reapply. NYX Lip IV is also described as silky and hydrating, with several users noting it doesn’t attract hair and feels good even after blotting down to a stain. If comfort is the top priority, Butter Gloss has the stronger scoring advantage.

Butter Gloss scores higher for ease of use (90 vs 86) because it’s a straightforward gloss: swipe on, reapply as needed. Lip IV is still easy (86) and gets praise for its applicator, but it offers more than one way to wear it (glossy or blotted for stain), which can add a small learning curve. If you want the simplest “grab-and-go” option, Butter Gloss is slightly better; if you like adjusting finish through blotting, Lip IV is still beginner-friendly.

NYX Lip IV slightly leads in application score (89 vs 88). Reviews highlight a well-shaped wand that helps create clean lines and holds enough product. Butter Gloss also applies smoothly and is widely described as creamy; however, some users note it can go on a bit thick at first and then settles after a few minutes. Both can deliver an even glossy layer, but Lip IV’s applicator feedback gives it a small edge.

Both are lip products intended for skin contact, and both score well for skin compatibility (Butter Gloss 85; Lip IV 82). Butter Gloss’s higher comfort score (93) and frequent “not sticky” feedback suggest it may be the safer bet for users who are easily bothered by tacky textures. Lip IV reviews also describe it as hydrating and comfortable, but scent/taste notes (faint coconut) come up, which may matter if you prefer fragrance-free-feeling products.

As with any new lip product, it’s sensible to check the ingredient list (not fully provided here) and patch test if you’re prone to irritation.

NYX Butter Gloss scores much higher for shade range (88 vs 74), and the listing highlights a “wide variety” of shades. Lip IV’s lower shade score aligns with repeated buyer feedback about shade accuracy—several reviewers mention colors not matching online photos or swatches, and that shades can pull differently than expected. If you want confidence in choosing from many familiar gloss shades, Butter Gloss is stronger. If you pick Lip IV, it’s worth reading shade-specific reviews (and being prepared for slight differences from images).

Both products score extremely well for finish quality (Butter Gloss 91; Lip IV 90). Butter Gloss is repeatedly described as smooth, creamy, and glossy without feeling heavy, which supports a polished everyday finish. Lip IV is described as “wet shine” and tends to leave a natural-looking tint as it wears, so the finish can shift from glossy to more stain-like over time. If you want a steady gloss look, Butter Gloss is slightly ahead; if you like a glossy start with a softer finish later, Lip IV has the intended behavior.

NYX Lip IV is the clear winner for longevity (82 vs 72). Reviews commonly mention that after the initial gloss phase, the remaining tint can last for many hours and fades more evenly. NYX Butter Gloss has mixed wear feedback: several users report it doesn’t hold up well through eating and drinking and needs reapplication, though some still find it lasts a few hours. If you want fewer touch-ups, Lip IV is the better bet based on the provided data.

Butter Gloss scores higher for scent (80 vs 74), and at least one review mentions it “smells amazing.” Lip IV has multiple mentions of a faint coconut oil-like scent/taste, described as subtle and not cloying by some users. If you’re sensitive to scented lip products, Lip IV’s coconut note is worth considering; if you enjoy a pleasant lip-product scent, either could work depending on your preferences.

NYX Lip IV scores higher for durability (80 vs 74). For liquid lip products, durability typically shows up as how well the packaging holds up and how consistently the product performs as you use it. Lip IV’s slightly stronger packaging score and applicator feedback may contribute to this advantage. Butter Gloss remains a solid option, but the lower durability score suggests a slightly less robust overall experience compared with Lip IV in the provided scoring.

Butter Gloss leads on personalization (90 vs 80) thanks to its stronger shade range score and the flexibility of shades like “Sugar Glass” for layering and mixing (noted by reviewers). Lip IV still personalizes well through finish control—you can wear it glossy or blot it for a stain-like effect—but shade predictability appears less consistent based on reviews. If you want the most straightforward path to finding “your shade,” Butter Gloss has the advantage; if you want a tint that evolves during wear, Lip IV offers that style of customization.

NYX Lip IV scores higher for ingredient quality (72 vs 58). It also provides more formula context in the listing, including named additions like Magnesium, Vitamin B12, antioxidants, and coconut water, along with “water-breaking technology.” NYX Butter Gloss’s provided data focuses more on texture and finish, with less ingredient detail available here, which limits how much can be assessed beyond the score.

Neither product’s full ingredient list is included in the data provided, so if you avoid specific ingredients or flavors/scents, checking the packaging or official ingredient list before buying is still important.

Both products use tube-style packaging, with Lip IV scoring slightly higher (78 vs 76). Lip IV’s applicator is specifically praised in reviews for its shape and product pickup, which contributes to a better packaging experience. Butter Gloss packaging is standard and functional, but the score suggests it’s not a standout feature. For purse carry and quick application, both are practical; for applicator design, Lip IV appears a bit stronger.

NYX Butter Gloss is the value winner (value score 95 vs 85) and is priced much lower ($5.97 vs $11.97) while also having a higher overall score and very strong satisfaction. Reviews repeatedly frame it as performing like—or better than—more expensive glosses. NYX Lip IV can still be good value if you specifically want longer wear and a stain effect, but it costs more and comes in a smaller listed amount (0.16 oz vs 0.27 oz shown for Butter Gloss variants), so cost-per-wear may depend on how much you value the tint longevity.

Both are from NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP and score similarly for brand trust (Butter Gloss 84; Lip IV 81). Butter Gloss’s massive review volume and long-standing popularity in feedback can increase confidence that you’ll get a predictable gloss experience. Lip IV is also well-reviewed, but shade accuracy concerns create a small trust gap around expectations vs reality. Both include cruelty-free messaging in the listing details.

Butter Gloss leads strongly on customer satisfaction (95 vs 87) and has far more reviews (123,926 vs 11,794) with a higher star rating (4.5/5 vs 4.3/5). Common positives include creamy feel, comfort, shine, and strong value; the recurring complaint is mixed longevity. Lip IV feedback is also positive overall, with frequent praise for long-lasting color and hydration, but repeated mentions of shade differences from online images and occasional notes about feathering or wear variability.

Butter Gloss scores slightly higher for claim support (86 vs 83). Its core claims—smooth, non-sticky feel and sheer-to-medium glossy coverage—are broadly echoed in the aggregated review overview and individual reviews, with the main caveat being that longevity is mixed. Lip IV’s claims around wet shine and an over-time stain effect are supported by many reviews describing a lasting tint after the gloss wears off. However, shade presentation concerns (colors not matching images) weaken confidence in the “what you see is what you get” aspect of shade claims for Lip IV.

Butter Gloss scores higher for ethical transparency (92 vs 78). Both listings include cruelty-free messaging and note PETA acknowledgment for the brand, while Lip IV also states a vegan formula in the title. The provided data doesn’t include more detail on sourcing, sustainability, or full certification specifics, so this section reflects the given scores and the limited ethical information available.