CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss Eclair Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in Eclair is an affordable lip gloss designed to give lips a glossy, soft-looking finish with sheer to medium colour. It stands out for comfort, smooth application and strong customer satisfaction, though wear time appears less consistent than its texture and finish.
Expert reviewed
88
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in 02 Eclair is a liquid lip gloss presented in a tube or bottle format with a doe-foot style applicator. It is positioned as a glossy lip makeup product with a buttery, silky texture and sheer to medium coverage, designed for users who want shine, softness and easy everyday wear rather than a heavy or fully opaque lip look. The provided shade information places Eclair in a medium-intensity pink direction, with a warm undertone noted in the specifications. This product appears aimed at broad use across skin tones and age groups, with all skin types listed in the product data. It also carries cruelty-free positioning in the provided details. Based on the review set and scoring profile, it is especially relevant for buyers looking for a low-cost gloss that feels comfortable on the lips, adds visible shine and can be used alone or as part of a wider lip makeup routine.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Item Form
Liquid
Finish Types
Glossy
Product Benefits
Softening,Smoothening,Makeup
Specialty
Cruelty Free
Skin Tone
All
Container Type
Tube or jar
Package Type Name
Tube or bottle with doe-foot applicator
Additional Features
Not-Tested-On-Animals
Lip Color Type
Lip Gloss
Lip Color Undertone
warm
Lip Color Shade Depth
Medium
Lip Color Intensity
Medium
Skin Type
All
Coverage
Medium,Sheer

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Color
02 Eclair
Age Range Description
All
Target Audience
All
Package Type Name
Tube or bottle with doe-foot applicator
Manufacturer
NYX Professional Makeup
UPC
800897818463
Global Trade Identification Number
00800897818463
Manufacturer Part Number
800897818463
Model Number
BLG02

Features & Specs

Item Form
Liquid
Finish Types
Glossy
Product Benefits
Softening,Smoothening,Makeup
Specialty
Cruelty Free
Skin Tone
All
Container Type
Tube or jar
Package Type Name
Tube or bottle with doe-foot applicator
Additional Features
Not-Tested-On-Animals
Lip Color Type
Lip Gloss
Lip Color Undertone
warm
Lip Color Shade Depth
Medium
Lip Color Intensity
Medium
Skin Type
All
Coverage
Medium,Sheer

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Color
02 Eclair
Age Range Description
All
Target Audience
All
Package Type Name
Tube or bottle with doe-foot applicator
Manufacturer
NYX Professional Makeup
UPC
800897818463
Global Trade Identification Number
00800897818463
Manufacturer Part Number
800897818463
Model Number
BLG02

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
0.69 x 0.69 x 3.59 inches; 0.52 ounces
Item model number
BLG02
UPC
800897818463
Manufacturer
NYX Professional Makeup

Scores breakdown

86 /100

Effectiveness

90 /100

Beauty results

82 /100

Skin compatibility

100 /100

Hair compatibility

88 /100

Shade range

91 /100

Finish quality

68 /100

Longevity

72 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • Very strong comfort profile, with a soft, creamy texture and many reviews describing it as non-sticky.
  • Glossy finish performs well, supported by a high finish quality score of 91.
  • Offers sheer to medium coverage that suits everyday lip makeup looks.
  • Excellent value, with a value score of 96 and repeated feedback that it performs above its price point.
  • Large review base and strong buyer sentiment, reflected in 4.5/5 stars from 123,967 reviews.
  • Cruelty-free positioning is clearly stated, with PETA-recognised brand messaging in the provided data.
  • Easy tube-and-applicator format makes quick touch-ups straightforward.

Limitations

  • Longevity is the clearest weakness, with mixed feedback on how well it lasts through eating and drinking.
  • Coverage is described as sheer to medium, so it may not suit buyers wanting fully opaque lip colour.
  • Colour payoff can vary by shade and by user, based on review comments across different variants.
  • Transfer resistance does not appear to be a strong point for this gloss format.
  • Packaging quality is solid rather than standout, with a score of 79.
  • Ingredient quality data is limited beyond the cruelty-free positioning, which restricts deeper ingredient assessment.

Ideal user profiles

  • Shoppers looking for an affordable everyday lip gloss with a glossy finish.
  • Users who prefer a comfortable, creamy lip product over tackier gloss formulas.
  • Buyers who want a flattering pink gloss for quick daily makeup looks.
  • People who are happy to reapply lip gloss during the day in exchange for comfort and shine.

Use cases

  • Everyday makeup routines.
  • Quick glossy lip touch-ups.
  • Natural or soft glam lip looks.
  • Layering over lip liner or other lip colour.
  • Low-cost beauty bag staples.
  • Travel or on-the-go lip makeup.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This product sits clearly in the makeup category, specifically within lip gloss. Its main role in a routine is to add shine, a soft tint and a smoother-looking lip finish with minimal effort. Compared with more opaque lip products, it appears more focused on comfort, gloss and everyday wearability than on full coverage or long-lasting colour. That makes it a practical option for quick daily makeup, touch-ups and pairing with lip liner or other lip products.

Best for

This gloss is best suited to shoppers who want an inexpensive, comfortable lip product with a glossy finish and easy application. It is a particularly good fit for everyday makeup wearers, people who dislike sticky gloss textures, and buyers who value soft shine over maximum staying power. Its high customer satisfaction, strong comfort score and low price point make it appealing for routine use.

Not best for

It may be less suitable for buyers who want a long-wear lip product that stays in place through meals, drinks or extended wear without touch-ups. It is also not the strongest choice for those seeking fully opaque coverage or highly detailed ingredient-led formulation transparency, since the provided data is stronger on finish and user experience than on formula depth.

Beauty results

The visible result is a glossy, smoother-looking lip finish with a soft tint rather than a dense, full-coverage colour layer. Reviews repeatedly point to a flattering shine and comfortable look on the lips, while the high beauty result score suggests it performs especially well when the goal is a polished, everyday gloss effect.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 86, NYX Butter Gloss appears to perform its core job well: adding gloss, softness and a wearable tint to the lips. The product description and reviews align closely on texture, with repeated mentions of a buttery feel, smooth glide and a non-sticky finish. That consistency supports its effectiveness as an everyday lip gloss rather than a long-wear lip colour. The main performance concern is wear time, since multiple reviews note that eating or drinking can reduce the finish and require reapplication. Within its intended use, though, it appears to deliver a reliable glossy lip result at a low price.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 90 reflects one of the product's clearest strengths. This gloss appears to leave lips looking smoother, shinier and more polished, with enough tint to enhance natural lip colour without necessarily becoming fully opaque. Reviews often describe the finish as pretty, natural-looking and flattering for everyday wear, which fits well with the product's glossy lip makeup positioning.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score of 82 suggests a generally solid fit for broad use, and the specifications list all skin types. Since this is a lip product, the most relevant point is user comfort on the lips rather than broader facial skin compatibility. The provided data supports a smooth, soft feel, but ingredient detail is limited, so highly sensitive users should still check the full formula before purchase.

Shade range

The shade range score of 88 suggests Butter Gloss performs well as a line with meaningful colour variety. The provided details mention a wide range of shades, and reviews across multiple variants describe strong satisfaction with colour selection. That said, user comments also suggest some shades can appear differently in real wear versus expectations, so checking swatches or shade references before buying may still be useful.

How it compares

Within the lip gloss category, this product appears stronger than average for comfort, finish and value. The buttery texture, glossy result and high customer satisfaction score help it stand out as a practical everyday gloss, especially for buyers who do not want a sticky feel. It also performs well on ease of use and general application, which supports its low-maintenance appeal. Where it looks less competitive is long wear, since the available data suggests staying power is more mixed than its finish and comfort. Overall, it seems better positioned as an affordable, wearable gloss than as a long-lasting lip product.

Ranking summary

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in Eclair ranks as a strong lip gloss option because it combines standout comfort, an attractive glossy finish and unusually strong value at a low price. Its overall score of 88 is supported by excellent sub-scores for comfort, value, customer satisfaction, finish quality and ease of use. The product's broad appeal is reinforced by a very large review base and consistent praise for texture and non-sticky wear. The main reason it does not score even higher is longevity, which is notably weaker at 68 and remains the clearest compromise for buyers who want fewer touch-ups.

Buying advice

Consider this product if you want an affordable gloss that feels comfortable, adds soft pink colour and gives a shiny finish without a heavy sticky texture. It makes the most sense for everyday makeup users, students, budget-conscious shoppers and anyone who is happy to reapply gloss through the day. If you want strong staying power, full opacity or a more ingredient-led premium formula, this may be less suitable. Before buying, it is worth checking shade references for Eclair specifically, since lip colour can appear differently depending on natural lip tone and application style.
88
Overall score

Final verdict

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in Eclair is a strong option in the affordable lip gloss category. Its main strength is the combination of comfort, smooth texture and glossy finish, all backed by very high customer satisfaction and excellent value. The main limitation is wear time, which appears less reliable than the rest of its performance profile. For shoppers who prioritise feel, shine and ease of use over long-lasting wear, it looks like a very sensible buy. For those wanting a gloss that survives meals with minimal touch-ups, it may feel more average than exceptional.
Back to review

Key topics

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss Eclair review, NYX Butter Gloss Eclair, non-sticky lip gloss review, pink lip gloss NYX, affordable lip gloss, glossy lip makeup, cruelty free lip gloss, sheer to medium coverage lip gloss, NYX lip gloss review

Frequently asked questions

Is NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in Eclair a good everyday lip gloss?
It appears to be a strong everyday option if you want comfortable shine rather than maximum wear time. The formula is described as buttery, smooth and generally non-sticky, while the glossy finish and sheer-to-medium coverage make it easy to wear for casual daily makeup looks.
How long does NYX Butter Gloss usually last?
Longevity is the main trade-off. The product has a longevity score of 68, and review feedback is mixed. Some users say it lasts a few hours, while others note that eating and drinking reduce wear noticeably, so most buyers should expect to reapply during the day.
Is NYX Butter Gloss sticky?
Most of the provided feedback suggests it feels less sticky than many traditional lip glosses. Several reviewers specifically praise the smooth, creamy texture and say it becomes soft and comfortable on the lips. A few comments mention slight tackiness at first, but not as a lasting issue.
What kind of finish does NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss have?
It has a glossy finish. The finish quality score of 91 supports that this is one of the product's strongest areas. Reviews frequently mention natural shine, a smooth look on the lips, and a flattering everyday gloss effect rather than a flat or heavy finish.
Is NYX Butter Gloss full coverage?
Not usually. The provided specifications describe coverage as sheer to medium, and that matches the broader product positioning. Some individual shades may appear more pigmented on certain users, but based on the listed data this gloss is better viewed as a gloss with tint rather than a fully opaque lip colour.
Does NYX Butter Gloss offer good value for money?
Yes, value looks like one of its strongest selling points. At the listed price of 5.97, combined with a value score of 96 and repeated customer comments comparing it favourably with pricier alternatives, it stands out as a budget-friendly lip gloss with strong user satisfaction.
Is NYX Butter Gloss suitable for sensitive skin or lips?
The product is listed for all skin types, and its skin compatibility score is 82, which suggests a generally solid profile. However, the ingredient information provided here is limited, so anyone with very reactive skin or lip sensitivity should still review the full ingredient list and patch test if needed.
What are the main limitations of NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss?
The main limitation is wear time. It may transfer easily and often needs reapplication after meals or drinks. It is also not the best match for shoppers wanting full coverage or a highly long-wearing lip product, since the formula is positioned more around comfort and glossy appearance.

Related Guides & Rankings

BestLand 3Pcs Matte Liquid Lip Gloss Set Review BestLand 3Pcs Matte Liquid Lip Gloss Set Review Maybelline Lifter Gloss Review: Hydrating Lip G... Maybelline Lifter Gloss Review: Hydrating Lip G... e.l.f. Lip Lacquer Review: Hydrating Clear Lip... e.l.f. Lip Lacquer Review: Hydrating Clear Lip... Lip Smacker Lippy Pals Review: Flavored Lip Bal... Lip Smacker Lippy Pals Review: Flavored Lip Bal...