CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

Maybelline Lifter Gloss Review

Maybelline Lifter Gloss is a high-shine lip gloss designed to add hydration, smooth-looking shine, and a fuller-looking lip effect. The Ice shade is a translucent pink-neutral option that suits understated everyday makeup. Its main limitation is wear time, which appears more moderate than long-lasting.
Expert reviewed
86
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

Maybelline Lifter Gloss is a liquid lip gloss in a tube format, positioned as a hydrating, high-shine makeup product with hyaluronic acid. The shade reviewed here, Ice, is described as a translucent pink with a cool undertone and light depth, making it a softer, more natural-looking option rather than a bold colour statement. The formula is intended to give lips a glossy, smoother-looking finish while offering a comfortable feel and easy application through an XL wand. Based on the provided data, this product is aimed at adults who want a simple lip gloss that fits easily into an everyday routine. Reviews consistently highlight shine, texture, and hydration as key strengths, while wear time and the plumping effect receive more mixed feedback. With a large review base and a mainstream price point, it sits firmly in the accessible everyday makeup category.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Item Form
Liquid
Finish Types
High-Glossy
Product Benefits
Hydrating, Plumping
Special Ingredients
Hyaluronic Acid
Skin Tone
All
Container Type
Tube
Package Type Name
Bottle
Additional Features
Not-Applicable
Lip Color Type
Lip Gloss
Lip Color Undertone
Cool
Lip Color Shade Depth
light
Lip Color Intensity
Moderate to High
Skin Type
Normal
Coverage
Full

Item details

Brand Name
MAYBELLINE
Color
02 ICE
Age Range Description
Adult
Country as Labeled
United States
Target Audience
Women
Package Type Name
Bottle
Manufacturer
Maybelline New York
UPC
041554583861
Manufacturer Part Number
041554583861
Model Number
041554583861

Product details

Product Dimensions
0.9 x 0.9 x 3.74 inches; 1.76 ounces
Item model number
041554583861
UPC
041554583861
Manufacturer
Maybelline New York

Scores breakdown

84 /100

Effectiveness

88 /100

Beauty results

81 /100

Skin compatibility

2 /100

Hair compatibility

86 /100

Shade range

92 /100

Finish quality

66 /100

Longevity

80 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • High finish quality score reflects a glossy, smooth-looking result that stands out in this category.
  • Reviews repeatedly describe the texture as comfortable, smooth, and less sticky than many lip gloss formulas.
  • The XL wand and tube format support fast, easy application in one swipe.
  • Hydration is one of the most consistent positives in both the product description and customer feedback.
  • Shade availability appears broad, with 20 shades and multiple neutral, sheer, and modern options mentioned.
  • Strong customer satisfaction is supported by a 4.5/5 average from 56,066 reviews.

Limitations

  • Longevity is only moderate, with mixed feedback on how long the gloss lasts through the day.
  • The plumping or fuller-look effect appears subtle rather than dramatic based on customer feedback.
  • Scent and taste may be a drawback for some users, with reactions ranging from pleasant to off-putting.
  • Some shades appear quite sheer, so buyers wanting strong pigment may find the colour payoff softer than expected.
  • One review notes that the package can feel large relative to the amount of product inside.
  • Ethical and ingredient transparency details are limited in the provided data.

Ideal user profiles

  • Users who want a comfortable everyday lip gloss with strong shine and light-to-moderate tint.
  • People with dry lips looking for a gloss that feels more hydrating than traditional sticky formulas.
  • Buyers who prefer easy one-swipe application and low-maintenance touch-ups.
  • Shoppers seeking an affordable mainstream gloss from a widely known makeup brand.

Use cases

  • Everyday makeup looks that need quick shine and a polished finish.
  • Layering over lip liner or lipstick for added gloss and softness.
  • Simple daytime lip makeup for work, errands, or casual wear.
  • Adding a subtle pink-neutral gloss effect with the Ice shade.
  • Touch-up friendly routines where reapplication is acceptable.
  • Lip looks focused more on comfort and shine than long wear.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This product sits in the makeup category, specifically within lip gloss. Its main role in a routine is to add shine, a smoother-looking lip finish, and light-to-moderate colour while keeping lips feeling comfortable. It can be worn alone for a natural glossy look or layered over lip liner or lipstick for more definition. Compared with more long-wear lip products, it appears positioned more around finish, comfort, and ease of use than durability.

Best for

Maybelline Lifter Gloss looks best suited to users who want a glossy lip product that feels comfortable and easy to apply. It is a strong fit for everyday makeup wearers, people who like subtle or natural-looking lip colour, and buyers who prioritise shine and hydration over all-day wear. The Ice shade in particular should appeal to those who want a soft pink-neutral gloss that layers well and works across many simple makeup looks.

Not best for

This gloss may be less suitable for shoppers who want intense pigment, a dramatic plumping effect, or extended wear without reapplication. Buyers who are sensitive to scent or taste may also want to be cautious, as feedback in that area is mixed. If you prefer a very lightweight, barely-there formula or want a strongly evidence-backed treatment-style lip product, this may not be the best match.

Beauty results

The visible result is a polished, high-shine lip look with a smoother surface appearance and a soft fuller-look effect created mainly through gloss and hydration. In the Ice shade, the finish is more translucent and neutral than opaque, so the effect leans natural, fresh, and wearable rather than bold.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 84, Maybelline Lifter Gloss appears to perform well at its main job: delivering shine, a comfortable feel, and a hydrated-looking lip finish. The data strongly supports its gloss performance, with frequent praise for texture, ease of application, and moisture feel. The XL wand and one-swipe format also reinforce its practical effectiveness for quick use. Where performance is less consistent is in longer wear and the plumping claim. Reviews suggest that any fuller-look effect is usually subtle, and staying power is good for some users but not for all.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 88 reflects a reliably attractive lip finish. This gloss is mainly praised for creating a smooth, glossy, polished look that makes lips appear healthier and more defined. Ice appears to give a softer translucent pink effect rather than bold colour payoff, so the result is best described as natural high shine with a flattering everyday finish.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score of 81 is solid for a lip product, though the provided data is more about lip feel than broad skin-type testing. Reviews often describe the gloss as comfortable and hydrating, with no strong pattern of irritation mentioned. However, scent and flavour feedback is mixed, so users who are sensitive around the lip area may want to patch test or check the ingredient list first.

Shade range

The shade range score of 86 suggests this gloss performs well on choice and versatility. The brand states that the line is available in 20 shades, including pearl, amber, crystal, Topaz, and other modern options. Reviews also mention multiple flattering neutrals and subtle shades. Ice appears especially versatile for users who want a sheer pink-neutral gloss, though buyers seeking strong colour intensity may prefer a deeper shade in the range.

How it compares

Within its category, this product appears stronger than average for finish quality, user comfort, and overall ease of application. It is the kind of gloss that stands out more for making lips look smooth, glossy, and well cared for than for offering exceptional wear time. Compared with many lip glosses, the lower-sticky feel and practical applicator are clear advantages, and the high review volume adds confidence. Its weaker comparative areas are longevity and claim strength around plumping, where user experience is more mixed. Overall, it looks more competitive as an everyday hydrating gloss than as a transformative plumping or long-wear lip product.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 86, Maybelline Lifter Gloss ranks as a very strong option in the lip gloss category. Its highest-performing areas are finish quality, ease of use, application, customer satisfaction, comfort, and beauty result, which together point to a product that is easy to wear and consistently delivers a polished glossy look. It is especially compelling for shoppers who want shine and hydration from an affordable mainstream formula. The main reasons it does not score even higher are moderate longevity, mixed feedback on the plumping effect, and some scent-related hesitation. In short, it ranks well because its core gloss performance is strong, even if a few secondary claims are less consistent.

Buying advice

Consider this gloss if you want a comfortable, high-shine lip product for everyday use and do not mind reapplying after a few hours. It is especially worth considering if you prefer sheer-to-moderate colour, a smooth glossy finish, and an accessible price point from a familiar brand. The Ice shade is a sensible choice for a subtle pink-neutral look. You may want to skip it if you need strong pigment, truly long wear, or a dramatic plumping result. Before buying, check shade swatches carefully, especially if you want more colour depth, and keep scent sensitivity in mind since reactions to smell and taste are mixed.
86
Overall score

Final verdict

Maybelline Lifter Gloss is a strong option in the drugstore lip gloss category. Its biggest strengths are its glossy finish, comfortable non-sticky texture, and easy one-swipe application, all of which are backed by high scores and a very large base of positive reviews. The main limitation is that wear time is only moderate, and the plumping effect appears subtle rather than dramatic. For shoppers who want a hydrating-looking everyday gloss with a polished finish, it performs well. For those seeking bold pigment, all-day longevity, or a more obvious lip-plumping effect, it is a less complete fit.
Back to review

Key topics

Maybelline Lifter Gloss review, Maybelline Lifter Gloss Ice, hydrating lip gloss with hyaluronic acid, high shine lip gloss review, pink neutral lip gloss, drugstore lip gloss, non sticky lip gloss, Maybelline lip gloss review, best hydrating lip gloss, gloss for dry lips

Frequently asked questions

Is Maybelline Lifter Gloss good for everyday wear?
It appears well suited to everyday use. The gloss has a high ease of use score, strong comfort score, and many reviewers describe it as smooth, non-sticky, and easy to wear. The main trade-off is moderate longevity, so some users may need to reapply during the day.
Does Maybelline Lifter Gloss actually plump lips?
The fuller-look claim seems to be more subtle than dramatic. Some reviewers say it helps lips look smoother or slightly fuller, likely through shine and hydration, while others say they noticed little to no plumping effect. Based on the provided data, hydration is better supported than strong plumping.
Is the Ice shade very pigmented?
No, the provided information describes Ice as a translucent pink shade. Reviews also suggest that several shades in the range give a softer, more subtle tint rather than bold colour. That makes Ice a better fit for a natural glossy look than for high-opacity colour coverage.
How long does Maybelline Lifter Gloss last?
Wear time appears average rather than especially long-lasting. The longevity score is 66, and customer feedback is mixed: some say it lasts decently, while others say it does not stay on all day. Buyers should expect some reapplication, especially after eating or drinking.
Is Maybelline Lifter Gloss sticky?
Most of the provided feedback suggests it is less sticky than many traditional glosses. Customers often describe the texture as smooth, thicker but comfortable, and easy to wear. That said, texture preferences are personal, so users who dislike gloss in general may still want to test it first.
Does Maybelline Lifter Gloss have a noticeable scent or taste?
Scent and taste seem noticeable to some users, but opinions vary. Some reviewers mention a pleasant vanilla, coconut, or chocolate-like note, while at least one reviewer disliked the smell. With a scent score of 68, this looks like a mild but somewhat polarising part of the user experience.
Who is Maybelline Lifter Gloss best for?
It is best for shoppers who want a glossy, hydrating lip product with easy application and a comfortable feel. It particularly suits users who like sheer-to-moderate colour, a smooth high-shine finish, and an affordable mainstream option. It is less ideal for those wanting strong pigment or extended wear.
Does Maybelline Lifter Gloss offer good value?
At the listed price of 9.98, it appears to offer solid value given its strong finish, comfort, and customer satisfaction scores. Reviews often describe it as high quality for the price. The main value limitation is that some users may need to reapply often, which can affect long-term cost efficiency.

Related Guides & Rankings

e.l.f. Lip Lacquer Review: Hydrating Clear Lip... e.l.f. Lip Lacquer Review: Hydrating Clear Lip... Lip Smacker Lippy Pals Review: Flavored Lip Bal... Lip Smacker Lippy Pals Review: Flavored Lip Bal... NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Review: Clear Lip Oil Gloss NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Review: Clear Lip Oil Gloss wet n wild MegaSlicks Lip Gloss Review: Nude Mood wet n wild MegaSlicks Lip Gloss Review: Nude Mood