CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner, Charcoal Review

Covergirl Perfect Point Plus is a twist-up charcoal eyeliner pencil designed for precise lines or softer, smudged eye makeup. It stands out for easy application, a built-in smudger, strong buyer satisfaction, and a low listed price. Its main limitation is inconsistent wear and durability feedback, including reports of smudging and breakage.
Expert reviewed
72
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner is an adult eye-makeup pencil in the Charcoal shade. It is designed to provide two application styles: a more defined line using its micro-fine point and a softer blended result using the built-in smudger tip. The twist-up pencil is described as self-sharpening, removing the need for a separate sharpener during routine use. At 0.08 ounces, it is a compact option for everyday makeup bags. The product appears aimed at buyers who want a low-maintenance pencil liner rather than a liquid liner or a traditional wood pencil. Its 4.4/5 rating from 26,820 reviews indicates broad customer interest, particularly around glide, control, and value. Still, the review overview identifies mixed feedback on colour, staying power, smudge resistance, and tip durability.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Item details

Brand Name
COVERGIRL
Number of Items
1
Age Range Description
Adult
Package Type Name
Tube
Manufacturer
Coty Beauty
UPC
022700632565
Manufacturer Part Number
00022700632565
Model Number
boi-opp-klo-uyi1351
Country as Labeled
United States

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
5.66 x 1.87 x 1.05 inches; 0.08 ounces
Item model number
boi-opp-klo-uyi1351
UPC
022700632565
Manufacturer
Coty Beauty

Scores breakdown

78 /100

Effectiveness

80 /100

Beauty results

52 /100

Skin compatibility

68 /100

Shade range

76 /100

Finish quality

63 /100

Longevity

58 /100

Ingredient quality

60 /100

Safety

Strengths

  • Micro-fine pencil format is designed for precise lining, while the built-in smudger supports softer eye looks.
  • High ease-of-use score of 88 reflects the convenient twist-up, no-sharpener format.
  • Application scored 84, supported by frequent feedback that the pencil glides on smoothly and is easy to control.
  • Beauty result scored 80, with users often praising bold colour and a polished lined or smoky finish.
  • Strong value score of 89 at the listed price of $4.46.
  • Customer satisfaction is high at 86, based on a 4.4/5 average from 26,820 reviews.
  • Covergirl is listed as Leaping Bunny Certified by Cruelty-Free International.

Limitations

  • Longevity score of 63 reflects mixed reports on all-day wear and smudge resistance.
  • Some reviewers report that the pencil tip or internal product can break during use.
  • Skin compatibility scored 52; one reviewer reported eye puffiness after use, although individual reactions vary.
  • Colour accuracy may be inconsistent across shades; one Midnight Blue reviewer found it more purple than navy.
  • The supplied information does not include a full ingredient list for detailed formula assessment.
  • Build quality and durability are moderate at 54 and 56, respectively.

Ideal user profiles

  • Makeup users seeking an affordable charcoal eyeliner for everyday definition.
  • People who prefer a twist-up pencil instead of maintaining a separate sharpener.
  • Users who want the option to create both a defined line and a softened smoky effect.
  • Buyers who value easy application and a large base of positive customer feedback.
  • Those looking for a less intense alternative to black eyeliner.

Use cases

  • Defining the upper lash line in an everyday makeup routine.
  • Creating a softer charcoal smoky-eye effect with the integrated smudger.
  • Quick eyeliner application when a separate pencil sharpener is inconvenient.
  • Pairing with mascara for a more defined eye-makeup look.
  • Subtle evening eye makeup where charcoal may feel less stark than black.
  • Touch-up-friendly makeup bags and travel kits, subject to the reported risk of tip breakage.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This is a makeup product, specifically a charcoal eye pencil for defining the lash line and creating blended eye looks. In a routine, it fits after eyelid prep and before or alongside mascara and eyeshadow. Its combination of a narrow twist-up point and a smudger makes it more versatile than a single-purpose precision liner, although it is not positioned in the supplied data as a guaranteed long-wear or waterproof formula.

Best for

This eyeliner is best for budget-conscious makeup users who want a charcoal shade, easy pencil control, and the choice between a neat line and a blurred finish. The high ease-of-use score of 88 and application score of 84 align with repeated comments about smooth glide and uncomplicated use. It is particularly practical for people who dislike carrying or cleaning a separate sharpener.

Not best for

It may not be the best match for buyers who need highly dependable all-day, smudge-resistant eye makeup, as longevity feedback is divided and the score is 63. It is also a cautious choice for people who have previously reacted to eye products, given one report of puffiness and a skin compatibility score of 52. Those prioritising robust pencil construction may be concerned by breakage reports.

Beauty results

The intended result is defined charcoal lining that can be left crisp or blended into a softer smoky effect. With a beauty result score of 80, the product appears capable of delivering visible colour and a polished eye-makeup finish for many users. Charcoal offers a less severe-looking option than black while still adding noticeable definition.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 78, Covergirl Perfect Point Plus appears to perform its core job well for many users: applying visible eyeliner with control and allowing a second, smudged finish. The supplied description supports this through the micro-fine point, twist-up mechanism, and smudger tip, while reviews frequently mention smooth glide. Effectiveness is held back by reports of product breakage and variable smudge resistance, which can affect the result over time.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 80 suggests a generally strong cosmetic payoff. Users commonly report bold-looking colour, smooth lines, and a finish that can range from defined to smoky. Charcoal is positioned as an eye-enhancing alternative to black, but the supplied data does not support a universal colour recommendation. Mixed shade-accuracy feedback in other variants means online swatches should be treated as guidance rather than certainty.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score is 52, a comparatively cautious result for an eye-area product. One reviewer reported an allergic-type reaction with eye puffiness after use, while other reviews report comfortable wear without irritation. These individual experiences cannot predict every user's response. The supplied information also lacks a full ingredient list, so people who are sensitive to eye cosmetics have limited formula detail to assess before purchasing.

Shade range

The shade range score of 68 reflects that the product is available in multiple colours, giving buyers some flexibility beyond Charcoal. The brand provides styling suggestions for different eye colours, though these are optional makeup ideas rather than performance evidence. Colour satisfaction is not uniform: some users praise shades, while one Midnight Blue review found the colour less navy than expected. Checking current shade images and names is worthwhile.

How it compares

Within the eyeliner category, this product appears stronger for convenience and value than for maximum wear reliability. Its 88 ease-of-use score and 89 value score make the twist-up pencil and integrated smudger especially appealing to buyers who want a quick, low-tool routine. The 80 beauty result and 84 application scores also suggest a good chance of achieving a defined or softly blended look. Compared with a category ideal, its weaker points are formula transparency, durability, and consistency of smudge resistance. It is best viewed as a flexible everyday pencil rather than a specialist long-wear option.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 72, Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner ranks as a solid budget-oriented option rather than a top-tier performance pick. Its strongest areas are value (89), ease of use (88), customer satisfaction (86), application (84), and visible makeup result (80). The twist-up pencil and built-in smudger provide clear routine convenience. Its ranking is limited by lower skin compatibility (52), build quality (54), durability (56), and only moderate longevity (63). The large 4.4/5 review base supports its popularity, but the recurring breakage and variable-smudging reports prevent a more decisive recommendation.

Buying advice

Consider this eyeliner if you want an inexpensive Charcoal pencil that is easy to apply, does not require a separate sharpener, and includes a smudger for softer eye makeup. It is particularly worth considering when quick application and value matter more than flawless all-day wear. Before buying, check the exact shade and current listing details, since colour impressions can vary. People prone to reactions around the eyes should review the full package ingredients if available and use added caution. Skip it if dependable transfer resistance, extended wear, or highly robust pencil construction are your non-negotiables.
72
Overall score

Final verdict

Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner in Charcoal is a strong budget eyeliner option for everyday definition and easy smoky looks. Its main strengths are smooth-feeling application, the practical twist-up format, an integrated smudger, high customer satisfaction, and excellent value at the listed price. The main limitation is inconsistency: some users report good wear and durability, while others experience smudging or breakage. Its 72 overall score reflects that balance. It is a sensible choice for users who want an uncomplicated charcoal pencil, but not the most dependable option for sensitive eyes or demanding long-wear makeup.
Back to review

Key topics

Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner, Covergirl charcoal eyeliner review, self sharpening eyeliner pencil, charcoal eye pencil, smudger tip eyeliner, affordable drugstore eyeliner, Covergirl eyeliner review

Frequently asked questions

Is Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner in Charcoal good for everyday eye makeup?
It appears well suited to everyday eye definition for users who want a charcoal pencil with a straightforward twist-up format. Its beauty result score is 80, ease-of-use score is 88, and reviewers frequently mention smooth application. Wear performance is less certain, however, as reports on smudging and all-day longevity are mixed.
Does Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner need a sharpener?
No separate sharpener is intended to be needed. The product is described as having a self-sharpening twist-up design that replenishes the liner point. One long-term reviewer noted that the mechanism does not necessarily recreate a traditional freshly sharpened point, but still found the narrow application surface useful for controlled lining.
Can this eyeliner create a smoky look?
Yes, the pencil includes a built-in soft smudger tip intended to blend the applied liner into a softer, smokier effect. This is one of its clearest practical advantages over a basic pencil format. Results will still depend on technique and wear conditions, since some users report that the formula can smudge more than they prefer.
How long does Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner last?
The longevity score is 63, indicating moderate but inconsistent wear. Some reviewers say the eyeliner remains in place through the day, including in warm conditions, while others say it does not last all day or smudges easily. It may be sensible to check wear on your own eyelids before relying on it for long events.
Is Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner suitable for sensitive eyes?
The available data does not establish that this eyeliner is suitable for sensitive eyes. Its skin compatibility score is 52, and one reviewer reported puffy eyes after use. That does not show how everyone will respond, but people with a history of reactions to eye makeup should review the available product information and use appropriate caution.
What are the main drawbacks of this Covergirl eyeliner?
The main drawbacks are variable wear, occasional breakage, and uncertainty around formula details. Reviews are divided on smudge resistance and lasting power, while some users report a broken tip or product core. Shade feedback can also vary, and the supplied listing does not provide a full ingredient list for closer assessment.
Is the Charcoal shade a good alternative to black eyeliner?
Charcoal can be a practical choice for users seeking defined eyes without the full intensity of black. The brand specifically suggests charcoal as an option for blue eyes, but this is styling guidance rather than a universal rule. The supplied reviews include a Charcoal user who liked the colour, though that reviewer also experienced breakage.
Does Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner offer good value?
It scores 89 for value and is listed at $4.46, making it a budget-oriented eyeliner option. Positive feedback often highlights easy application, bold-looking colour, and the convenience of the smudger and twist-up design. Value is reduced for buyers who encounter breakage or find that the wear time does not meet their needs.

Related Guides & Rankings

Maybelline Unstoppable Onyx Eyeliner Review Maybelline Unstoppable Onyx Eyeliner Review Revlon Universal Points Sharpener Makeup Tool R... Revlon Universal Points Sharpener Makeup Tool R... Julep When Pencil Met Gel Bronze Shimmer Eyelin... Julep When Pencil Met Gel Bronze Shimmer Eyelin... Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner Review Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner Review