CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

Julep When Pencil Met Gel Eyeliner Review

Julep When Pencil Met Gel is a sharpenable gel eyeliner pencil designed for defined, richly pigmented eye looks. Its strongest points are smooth application, colour payoff and flexible shade options, while wear resistance and pencil durability receive more mixed feedback.
Expert reviewed
76
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

Julep When Pencil Met Gel is a multi-use, sharpenable gel eyeliner pencil in Soft Black, a softer alternative to the deepest black liner look. The product is positioned as a waterproof, longwear pencil with a creamy gel texture, a smooth set and a claimed transfer-resistant finish. It is intended for adult makeup users and is supplied as one 0.39-ounce pencil measuring 5 by 0.25 by 0.25 inches. Based on the supplied reviews and scores, the formula’s main appeal is its easy glide and strong initial colour. Reviewers also describe a short blending window before it sets, which can suit both precise lining and softer eye makeup. Results are not uniform, though: some users report reliable wear, while others find that it smudges or does not last. The sharpenable format can provide precision but is also a recurring source of breakage and usability complaints.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Item details

Brand Name
Julep
Number of Items
1
Age Range Description
Adult
Package Type Name
Tube
Manufacturer
Julep
UPC
814502021629
Manufacturer Part Number
0222-0001006_FBA
Model Number
0222-0001025

Product details

Product Dimensions
5 x 0.25 x 0.25 inches; 0.39 ounces
Item model number
0222-0001025
UPC
814502021629
Manufacturer
Julep

Scores breakdown

77 /100

Effectiveness

84 /100

Beauty results

72 /100

Skin compatibility

84 /100

Shade range

83 /100

Finish quality

70 /100

Longevity

55 /100

Ingredient quality

72 /100

Safety

Strengths

  • High application score of 85 reflects the repeatedly praised creamy, tug-free glide.
  • Beauty-result score of 84 supports rich colour and a polished eye-defining effect.
  • Shade range and personalization both score 84, with matte, shimmer, neutral and bolder colour options described.
  • Many reviewers report that the formula sets well and can be blended briefly before it does.
  • Comfort scores 81, with several reviews describing easy wear and no reported irritation in their individual experience.
  • At $9.70, it sits below many prestige pencil liners while retaining a gel-pencil format.

Limitations

  • Longevity is only 70: reported all-day wear is inconsistent, with some users experiencing smudging after a few hours.
  • Multiple customers report tip breakage or sharpening difficulties, reflected in modest durability and build scores.
  • Ingredient quality scores 55 because no ingredient list or detailed formulation transparency was provided.
  • The transfer-proof and 10-hour wear claims are not consistently reflected in the supplied reviews.
  • Sharpening uses product over time and may not suit buyers who prefer a retractable pencil.
  • Value perceptions are mixed despite the accessible listed price.

Ideal user profiles

  • Makeup users seeking a creamy gel eyeliner pencil with strong initial pigment.
  • Buyers who like to smudge or soften liner briefly before it sets.
  • People looking for softer alternatives to stark black, including brown, taupe, navy and terracotta tones.
  • Users comfortable maintaining a sharpenable pencil to achieve a fine point.
  • Those wanting a lower-priced alternative to higher-cost gel eyeliner pencils.

Use cases

  • Quick everyday lash-line definition.
  • Softened or blended eye looks before the formula sets.
  • Using Soft Black when a less intense line than blackest black is preferred.
  • Creating a precise line with a freshly sharpened point.
  • Pairing with eyeshadow for a more diffused eye look.
  • Adding colour definition with matte or shimmer variants in the wider range.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This is a makeup product, specifically a gel eyeliner pencil for lining the lash line and creating defined or softly blended eye looks. Its role in a routine is primarily cosmetic: adding depth, shape and colour around the eyes. Compared with liquid liner, its creamy pencil format appears more approachable for quick application and smudging. The broader range of matte and shimmer colours also makes it relevant to both neutral everyday makeup and more expressive colour looks.

Best for

Julep When Pencil Met Gel is best for makeup users who prioritize creamy, high-pigment application and want a pencil that can be softened before it sets. Its 85 application score, 84 beauty-result score and 84 shade-range score make it especially relevant for shoppers who enjoy choosing between softer neutrals and more noticeable colours. It is also a practical fit for users who prefer a sharpened point for detail work.

Not best for

This pencil may not be the best match for anyone who needs consistently proven smudge-proof wear across long days, oily-lid routines or conditions where transfer is a concern. Longevity scores 70 and reviews are divided on staying power. It may also frustrate buyers who dislike sharpening pencils or want a more robust format, since tip breakage and sharpening problems are repeated concerns. Ingredient-focused shoppers have limited information to assess.

Beauty results

The visible result is a smooth, pigmented eye line that can look crisp when applied with a sharp tip or softer when blended promptly. Soft Black offers an eye-defining effect that may appear less severe than the darkest black shades. The 84 beauty-result score and 83 finish-quality score align with reviews praising attractive colour, opacity and a smooth-looking finish.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 77, this eyeliner appears capable of delivering its central purpose: depositing visible colour in a smooth, controllable pencil format. Its strongest supporting evidence comes from frequent praise for creamy glide, pigment and easy lining. The product listing describes waterproof, up-to-10-hour performance, but supplied reviews do not show fully consistent wear; some report staying power while others report smearing or short wear. Effectiveness is therefore stronger for initial application and appearance than for universally dependable longwear performance.

Beauty results

The beauty-result score of 84 is one of the product’s best indicators. Reviews commonly highlight attractive colour, opaque-looking payoff and the ability to create either a subtle line or a more blended effect. Soft Black can suit users who want definition without the strongest possible black contrast. This score reflects the immediate cosmetic result rather than a guarantee that the finish will remain unchanged throughout the day.

Skin compatibility

Skin compatibility scores 72, a moderate result for an eye-area product. The listing says the pencil is ophthalmologist-tested and appropriate for sensitive eyes and waterlines, and a supplied reviewer reported no irritation in their personal use. However, individual sensitivity varies and the provided data does not include a full ingredient list. Users with known eye-area sensitivities should review available label information and use caution if discomfort develops.

Shade range

The shade-range score of 84 reflects a broad stated selection of richly pigmented matte and shimmer shades, spanning soft neutrals through bolder colours. Review feedback mentions black, brown, taupe, green, navy, violet and terracotta variants, suggesting options beyond standard black liner. Soft Black itself may appeal to people seeking a more muted definition. No detailed undertone chart or shade-by-shade availability information was provided.

How it compares

Within the gel eyeliner pencil category, this product appears stronger for initial payoff, ease of glide and colour choice than for long-term reliability. Its 85 application score and 84 scores for beauty result and shade range indicate a competitive cosmetic experience for users who want smooth, pigmented liner. By contrast, its 60 durability score and 70 longevity score suggest it is less compelling for shoppers who prioritize consistently transfer-resistant wear and a fault-free pencil mechanism. At the listed price, it occupies a budget-conscious position, but mixed value feedback means performance consistency is central to whether it feels worthwhile.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 76, Julep When Pencil Met Gel ranks as a solid but not fully consistent gel eyeliner pencil. It earns its position through excellent application (85), appealing beauty results (84), strong shade variety (84) and a comfortable creamy feel (81). These strengths are reinforced by many reviews praising pigment, glide and the ability to blend before setting. Its ranking is held back by lower ingredient quality (55), durability (60), build quality (62) and only moderate longevity (70). In practical terms, it appears more dependable for immediate colour and application than for guaranteed all-day, problem-free wear.

Buying advice

Consider Julep When Pencil Met Gel if you want a creamy, sharpenable gel pencil for everyday definition, a softened liner look or colour beyond basic black. Soft Black may be especially useful if you prefer a dark line with less visual intensity than blackest black. Before buying, note that longwear results vary and that the pencil must be sharpened. If you have sensitive eyes or ingredient preferences, check the current label information because a full ingredient list was not included here. Buyers who require reliable no-transfer performance should test wear before choosing it for important occasions.
76
Overall score

Final verdict

Julep When Pencil Met Gel is a strong option for creamy application, rich colour and flexible eye looks, but a more limited choice for buyers who need uniformly dependable longwear. Its main strength is the high-quality initial application: it glides on smoothly, offers a brief blending window and earns high scores for finish and visible result. Its main limitation is inconsistency, particularly around smudge resistance, sharpening and tip durability. With an overall score of 76 and a $9.70 listed price, it is worth considering for users comfortable with a sharpenable pencil and willing to assess wear in their own routine.
Back to review

Key topics

Julep When Pencil Met Gel review, Julep Soft Black eyeliner, sharpenable gel eyeliner pencil, longwear eyeliner review, waterproof gel eyeliner, transfer-proof eyeliner pencil, Julep eyeliner pencil

Frequently asked questions

Is Julep When Pencil Met Gel a good everyday eyeliner?
It appears well suited to everyday eye definition for users who value creamy application and visible pigment. Its beauty-result score is 84 and application score is 85, while several reviewers describe a quick, easy routine. Wear performance is less predictable, however, so users prone to liner transfer may want to test it during a typical day.
Does the Julep Soft Black eyeliner stay on all day?
The listing states up to 10 hours of wear, and some reviewers report all-day staying power. However, the longevity score is 70 and feedback is mixed: other users say the liner smears within a few hours or runs in their routine. The supplied evidence does not establish consistent all-day wear for every user.
Is this eyeliner easy to apply?
Application is one of its stronger areas, with an application score of 85 and an ease-of-use score of 75. Reviews frequently mention a creamy glide, opaque initial payoff and the ability to blend before setting. The main practical drawback is the sharpenable format, which can be frustrating for users who encounter breakage or sharpening issues.
Is Julep When Pencil Met Gel suitable for sensitive eyes?
The product listing says it is ophthalmologist-tested and intended to be safe for sensitive eyes and waterlines. Its skin compatibility and safety scores are both 72, and one reviewer reported no irritation in personal use. Individual tolerance differs, and no full ingredient list was supplied, so cautious users should check available product information and stop use if discomfort occurs.
What finish does the Julep eyeliner pencil provide?
The range includes both matte and shimmer shades, while this page concerns the Soft Black version. Finish quality scores 83, supported by reviews that describe smooth, rich-looking colour rather than a dry or skipping line. The final effect can be kept defined or softened shortly after application, depending on technique.
What are the main drawbacks of Julep When Pencil Met Gel?
The most repeated concerns are uneven smudge resistance, tip breakage and inconsistent sharpening. Durability scores 60, build quality scores 62 and packaging quality scores 68, indicating that the pencil format is less dependable than its colour and application performance. Ingredient transparency is also limited in the data provided.
Does this Julep eyeliner offer good value?
At a listed price of $9.70, it may appeal to shoppers seeking a gel-pencil experience without a higher prestige-pencil price. The value score is 72, but feedback is mixed. Buyers who get smooth application and dependable wear may find it worthwhile; those affected by breakage, rapid use from sharpening or smudging may feel differently.
Who is Julep When Pencil Met Gel best for?
This eyeliner is best for people who want a pigmented, creamy pencil that can create a simple defined or lightly blended eye look. It is particularly relevant for users who enjoy sharpening pencils for precision and want access to varied colours and finishes. It is less compelling for buyers who require reliably transfer-resistant wear in every routine.

Related Guides & Rankings

wet n wild Mega Last Liquid Eyeliner Review wet n wild Mega Last Liquid Eyeliner Review COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil Review COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil Review