CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer Review: Matte Makeup Base

Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer is a lightweight cream makeup primer designed to create a smoother, more matte-looking base before foundation or concealer. It scores especially well for shine control, wear time, ease of use and value, with strong feedback from oily-skin users. However, some users report dryness, flaking or a chalky finish.
Expert reviewed
78
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer 003 is a 1 oz cream primer intended to prepare skin for makeup while reducing the appearance of shine. The supplied listing describes an ultra-lightweight formula with a matte finish, lightweight coverage and a skin-perfecting role. It is presented for all skin types and tones, although its performance profile and buyer feedback make it most relevant for people whose makeup tends to look shiny, particularly through the T-zone. The product is designed to sit underneath complexion makeup, helping it apply over a more even-looking, less greasy-feeling base. Some reviewers also use it on its own for a soft matte appearance. Its low listed price and high review volume make it a notable budget primer, but the available data also shows that its strongly mattifying effect may not suit people who experience dryness or prefer a more luminous finish.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Product Benefits
Smoothening
Item Form
Cream
Skin Type
All
Container Type
Bottle
Specialty
Ultra
Finish Types
Matte
Skin Tone
All
Coverage
Lightweight Formula

Item details

Brand Name
Rimmel
Country as Labeled
Great Britain
Number of Items
1
Manufacturer
Coty Beauty
Global Trade Identification Number
03607342682757
Manufacturer Part Number
34788826003
Model Number
34788826003

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
1.18 x 1.81 x 4.29 inches; 1.48 ounces
Item model number
34788826003
Manufacturer
Coty Beauty

Scores breakdown

84 /100

Effectiveness

80 /100

Beauty results

70 /100

Skin compatibility

18 /100

Hair compatibility

58 /100

Shade range

78 /100

Finish quality

84 /100

Longevity

55 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • Strong value score of 91 for a 1 oz drugstore makeup primer.
  • High effectiveness score of 84, supported by repeated feedback about shine control.
  • Ultra-lightweight cream format was frequently described as smooth and non-greasy.
  • High longevity score of 84 for helping makeup maintain a matte appearance.
  • Works as a matte base alone or beneath complexion makeup according to reviews.
  • High customer satisfaction score of 86 from a large 20,011-review sample.

Limitations

  • Some reviewers report dryness, flaking, or an overly matte look.
  • A chalky or pale cast under makeup was reported by one reviewer.
  • Shine control may be less complete around the nose and chin for some users.
  • Ingredient quality score of 55 reflects limited ingredient information in the supplied data.
  • Ethical transparency is limited in the available product information.
  • The product is a single lightweight cream primer rather than a customizable shade or finish system.

Ideal user profiles

  • People with oily or combination areas seeking a more matte makeup base.
  • Budget-conscious shoppers looking for a low-cost drugstore primer.
  • Makeup wearers who prefer a lightweight, non-greasy cream texture.
  • Users who want to reduce visible shine before applying foundation or concealer.
  • People who may also use a matte primer alone for a less shiny skin appearance.

Use cases

  • Prepping the T-zone before foundation application.
  • Creating a matte base for everyday makeup routines.
  • Reducing the look of surface shine for workdays or evenings out.
  • Pairing with foundation and concealer when longer-lasting makeup is preferred.
  • Using sparingly in oil-prone areas rather than across the entire face.
  • Wearing alone for a lightweight, less shiny finish.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This is a makeup product, specifically a mattifying face primer used at the preparation stage of a complexion routine. Its main role is to provide a lightweight base before foundation, concealer or powder while helping reduce visible surface shine. Rather than adding coverage or colour, it focuses on finish, makeup adherence and a more matte overall appearance. It can also suit minimal-makeup routines when a less shiny look is the priority.

Best for

Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer appears best for budget-focused makeup wearers who want a lightweight matte base and have oily or combination areas. Its 84 effectiveness and longevity scores, alongside frequent feedback about all-day shine control, make it especially relevant for the T-zone and under foundation. It is also a practical choice for people who dislike greasy-feeling primers and want a simple cream formula.

Not best for

This primer may be less suitable for people with dry-feeling or flaky areas, or for those who prefer a dewy, flexible complexion finish. Some reviewers experienced flaking, an overly matte appearance or a chalky pale effect beneath makeup. Buyers who need detailed ingredient information may also want to investigate further, as the supplied data does not include a full ingredient list and ingredient quality scores only 55.

Beauty results

The intended result is a softer, less shiny complexion with a matte base that can make pores look less visible before makeup. Reviews often describe a velvety, smooth appearance and improved makeup presentation. The result can be very matte, however, and a small number of users found the finish dry-looking, pale or less smoothing than expected.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

With an effectiveness score of 84, Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer performs strongly for its core role: creating a less shiny makeup base. The listing highlights shine control and makeup preparation, and review feedback repeatedly mentions a smooth application, reduced oiliness and longer-lasting makeup. Several users with oily skin call it particularly effective, including when used on the T-zone. The key qualification is that results can vary by facial area and complexion product; one reviewer still experienced shine around the nose and chin, while another disliked the overall look under makeup.

Beauty results

The beauty result score of 80 reflects a generally successful matte, smooth-looking finish. Users commonly report reduced shine, softer-looking pores and a more polished base with or without makeup. The primer’s result is not universally flattering: feedback includes a chalky white effect and an overly matte appearance on some skin. It is therefore better aligned with a clearly matte preference than with a natural-dewy finish goal.

Skin compatibility

The skin compatibility score of 70 suggests a mixed but broadly workable profile. The listing states that it does not irritate skin or clog pores, and some users report comfortable use, including a reviewer who described sensitive-skin use positively. In contrast, the aggregated feedback and reviews include dryness and flaking concerns. People prone to dry patches should apply cautiously and assess how it layers with their usual makeup.

Finish quality

Its finish quality score of 78 points to a capable matte effect with a few important trade-offs. The cream is intended to make skin look less shiny without a greasy surface feel, and many reviews describe a smooth, velvety base. For some, the finish may go beyond soft matte and look overly flat, dry or pale beneath foundation. Thin application and makeup pairing are likely important to the final appearance.

How it compares

Within the makeup-primer category, this product appears more competitive for practical matte performance and low-cost value than for formula transparency or customization. Its 84 effectiveness and longevity scores suggest that it is well positioned for buyers prioritizing shine control and makeup wear, while the 91 value score is a standout. The lightweight, non-greasy feel is another relative strength. Compared with broader-use primers, its main compromise is the narrowly matte finish: dry or texture-prone skin may find it less forgiving, and the available data offers limited detail for ingredient-focused or ethics-focused shoppers.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 78, Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer ranks as a strong-value option in the mattifying primer category. Its best-performing areas are value at 91, customer satisfaction at 86, and effectiveness, longevity and ease of use at 84. These scores align with a large body of feedback praising the lightweight texture, shine control and ability to support makeup wear. Its position is held back by moderate ingredient quality at 55, low ethical transparency at 40, and compatibility concerns such as flaking, dryness or a chalky finish for some users. It is a practical specialist primer rather than a universally adaptable complexion base.

Buying advice

Consider Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer if your main goal is a more matte makeup base at a low price, especially if your T-zone becomes shiny during the day. It can be used beneath foundation or, based on reviews, alone for a lightweight less-shiny look. Before buying, check the current ingredient label if you have known cosmetic sensitivities, as a complete ingredient list was not supplied here. If you have dry patches or prefer a radiant finish, test a small amount first and assess it with your usual foundation, since some users report flaking or a pale, overly matte result.
78
Overall score

Final verdict

Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer is a strong budget mattifying primer, earning an overall score of 78 through its excellent value, high buyer satisfaction and reliable shine-control profile. Its main strength is the lightweight cream formula’s ability to create a less greasy, longer-wearing makeup base for many oily-skin users. Its main limitation is that the same strong matte effect can appear dry, flaky or chalky for some complexions. It is a sensible choice for shoppers who specifically want affordable oil-control support, but it is not the most versatile option for dry skin, dewy-finish preferences or ingredient-transparency priorities.
Back to review

Key topics

Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer, Rimmel Stay Matte Primer review, matte makeup primer, primer for oily skin, drugstore mattifying primer, shine control primer, lightweight face primer, Rimmel primer 003

Frequently asked questions

Is Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer good for oily skin?
It appears best suited to oil-prone areas based on its 84 effectiveness score and repeated reviewer feedback about reduced shine. Several users specifically liked it on oily skin and the T-zone. Results are not uniform, however: one review noted that the nose and chin could still become shiny during the day.
Does Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer feel heavy or greasy?
The supplied description presents this as an ultra-lightweight, non-greasy cream primer, and reviews generally support that experience. Its comfort score is 81, with multiple users describing a smooth, barely noticeable feel. Individual comfort can vary, particularly if a very matte finish feels drying on your skin.
How long does Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer last?
The listing says it controls shine for up to eight hours and helps makeup stay on through the day. Its longevity score is 84, while several reviews describe matte wear lasting all day or all night. These are user experiences and product claims, not a guarantee of identical wear time for every routine.
Can Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer be worn without foundation?
Yes, some reviewers reported applying it alone to reduce the appearance of shine and create a more matte-looking base. It is still primarily positioned as a makeup primer. If worn without makeup, use a small amount first, as some feedback indicates that the finish can look very matte or dry on certain complexions.
What are the main drawbacks of Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer?
The main reported drawbacks are dryness, flaking, and a potentially chalky or pale-looking finish under makeup for some users. Its ingredient quality score is also moderate at 55 because no full ingredient list was supplied. Oil control may be incomplete in areas such as the nose and chin.
Is Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer easy to apply?
It has an ease-of-use score of 84 and an application score of 82. The cream format is designed to be smoothed over skin before makeup, and reviews commonly describe it as smooth and straightforward to use. Applying a light, even layer, particularly across oil-prone areas, may help avoid an overly matte result.
Does Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer offer good value?
At the listed price of 5.97 for 1 oz, it earns a high value score of 91. Reviewers regularly call it affordable and compare its performance favourably with more expensive primers. Value still depends on how your skin responds, especially if you are prone to dryness, flaking, or a pale cast.
Are the product claims for Rimmel London Stay Matte Primer well supported?
Claim support scores 76, indicating reasonable but not complete support in the supplied information. Reviews broadly align with claims of a lightweight feel, matte shine control, and improved makeup wear. Claims about pore blurring, non-irritation, and eight-hour wear should be treated as product positioning and individual experience rather than universal outcomes.

Related Guides & Rankings

e.l.f. Poreless Face Primer Review: Matte Makeu... e.l.f. Poreless Face Primer Review: Matte Makeu...