CosmeticRanker
Menu

Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Lipstick Audrey Review

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Lipstick in Audrey is a high-pigment, full-coverage stick lipstick with a cool mid-tone blue-pink colour and a non-glossy matte finish. It scores strongly for visible finish, application and value, while comfort and transfer resistance are less consistent across buyer feedback.
Expert reviewed
84
Overall score
Data-driven scoring Expert reviewed Updated analysis

Why we ranked it highly

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Lipstick in Audrey is a stick-format lip colour designed to provide full coverage, high pigment and a silky matte look. Audrey is identified as a medium-depth, cool-toned blue pink, making it a more defined colour choice than a neutral or glossy everyday lip product. The listing describes a smooth, creamy application and names shea butter and cocoa butter as special ingredients. It is sold in a tube or casing with a standard twist-up lipstick format. The wider NYX matte lipstick range is stated to include 22 shades, from reds to nudes. Buyer feedback across the range frequently praises pigmentation, colour and smooth application, though it also identifies variation in dryness, colour accuracy and transfer. This makes Audrey most relevant to makeup users who prioritise a polished matte finish and saturated colour while accepting that preparation or touch-ups may improve wear.
90-day review Expert reviewed User feedback Data scoring

Key specs

Features & Specs

Item Form
Stick
Finish Types
Matte
Product Benefits
Smoothening
Special Ingredients
shea butter, cocoa butter
Specialty
Cruelty Free
Skin Tone
All
Container Type
Tube or casing
Package Type Name
Tube or casing
Additional Features
Smooth and creamy matte finish, cruelty-free brand
Lip Color Type
Lipstick
Lip Color Undertone
Cool
Lip Color Shade Depth
Medium
Lip Color Intensity
High Pigment
Skin Type
All
Coverage
Full

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Color
Audrey
Age Range Description
All
Country as Labeled
Taiwan
Target Audience
Women
Package Type Name
Tube or casing
Unit Count
1 Count
Manufacturer
NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc.
UPC
800897143862
Global Trade Identification Number
00800897143862
Manufacturer Part Number
NMLSL020-00
Model Number
MLS20

Features & Specs

Item Form
Stick
Finish Types
Matte
Product Benefits
Smoothening
Special Ingredients
shea butter, cocoa butter
Specialty
Cruelty Free
Skin Tone
All
Container Type
Tube or casing
Package Type Name
Tube or casing
Additional Features
Smooth and creamy matte finish, cruelty-free brand
Lip Color Type
Lipstick
Lip Color Undertone
Cool
Lip Color Shade Depth
Medium
Lip Color Intensity
High Pigment
Skin Type
All
Coverage
Full

Item details

Brand Name
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
Color
Audrey
Age Range Description
All
Country as Labeled
Taiwan
Target Audience
Women
Package Type Name
Tube or casing
Unit Count
1 Count
Manufacturer
NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc.
UPC
800897143862
Global Trade Identification Number
00800897143862
Manufacturer Part Number
NMLSL020-00
Model Number
MLS20

Product details

Is Discontinued By Manufacturer
No
Product Dimensions
1 x 1.69 x 3.19 inches; 0.03 ounces
Item model number
MLS20
UPC
800897143862
Manufacturer
NYX Cosmetics USA, Inc.

Scores breakdown

86 /100

Effectiveness

88 /100

Beauty results

72 /100

Skin compatibility

62 /100

Hair compatibility

86 /100

Shade range

90 /100

Finish quality

81 /100

Longevity

78 /100

Ingredient quality

Strengths

  • High-pigment, full-coverage colour in the Audrey mid-tone blue-pink shade.
  • Excellent matte finish score of 90/100, matching the product’s non-glossy finish positioning.
  • Strong application score of 89/100 for the straightforward twist-up stick format and smooth-glide description.
  • Available within a stated 22-shade matte lipstick range, with a strong shade-range score of 86/100.
  • Competitive value score of 87/100 at the listed price of 8.94.
  • Cruelty-free status is explicitly stated by the brand and supported by an ethical-transparency score of 84/100.
  • Large review base of 19,070 ratings with a 4.3/5 average.

Limitations

  • Comfort is mixed: some reviewers describe a creamy feel, while others report dryness on the lips.
  • Wear is not consistently transfer-resistant; reviewers mention smearing, migration and transfer to drinkware.
  • Colour can differ from listing images or expectations, based on reviews of other shades in the range.
  • The product has a cool undertone and medium depth, which may not suit every preferred lip look.
  • Only shea butter and cocoa butter are identified as special ingredients; a complete ingredient list was not provided.
  • Packaging quality is adequate rather than exceptional, with a score of 75/100.

Ideal user profiles

  • Makeup users seeking a high-pigment, classic matte lipstick in a cool blue-pink tone.
  • Buyers who prefer the speed and familiarity of a twist-up lipstick stick.
  • Those looking for full-coverage colour at an accessible price point.
  • Users who value a cruelty-free brand position and a broad shade selection.
  • People comfortable using lip liner, balm or occasional touch-ups to refine matte-lip wear.

Use cases

  • Everyday makeup when a defined, non-glossy lip is wanted.
  • Cool-toned pink lip looks with full colour coverage.
  • Quick application before work, events or social plans.
  • Layering with lip liner to improve edge definition.
  • Pairing with a small amount of lip balm underneath when additional comfort is preferred.
  • Building a more polished makeup look around a matte lip finish.

Fit and positioning

Who this works for

Category positioning

This is a makeup product, specifically a traditional bullet lipstick for adding opaque lip colour and a matte final effect. Its role in a routine is to create a defined lip look quickly, either as the focal point of minimal makeup or as part of a more complete complexion-and-eye look. Compared with lip glosses or sheer balms, Audrey is positioned around fuller pigment, less shine and a cool pink tone. The stick format also makes it practical for direct application and on-the-go touch-ups.

Best for

Audrey is best suited to buyers who want a cool-toned pink lipstick with strong colour payoff, full coverage and a clear matte finish. Its 88/100 beauty-result score, 90/100 finish score and 89/100 application score make it a good match for users who prioritise visible impact and simple stick application. It is also a compelling option for price-conscious shoppers, given its 87/100 value score and the brand’s stated cruelty-free status.

Not best for

This lipstick may not be the best match for people who need a highly transfer-resistant formula for meals, drinks or long periods without checking their lip colour. Reviews are divided on comfort: some find the formula creamy, while others find it drying or prone to smearing. Buyers who prefer glossy, sheer or warm-toned lipstick should also look elsewhere, as Audrey is a high-pigment, cool, medium-depth matte shade.

Beauty results

Audrey is designed to leave lips with a saturated, full-coverage blue-pink colour and a smooth non-glossy matte appearance. The 88/100 beauty-result score and 90/100 finish-quality score indicate that the final look is a central strength. It should appeal to users seeking a more polished, colour-forward lip than a balm, stain or gloss provides.

Performance analysis

How it performs in practice

Each scoring dimension is separated into a compact card so the strengths and tradeoffs are easier to compare without reading one long block.

Effectiveness analysis

NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey earns an effectiveness score of 86/100, reflecting a strong fit with its core purpose: delivering high-pigment matte lip colour in a simple stick format. The listing specifies full coverage, a smooth glide and a non-glossy finish, while reviews commonly praise pigmentation and ease of application. Wear performance is generally positive, but not uniform. Some buyers report all-day staying power, whereas others mention smearing, migration or transfer. It appears most effective when the priority is visible colour and matte definition rather than completely worry-free wear.

Beauty results

The 88/100 beauty-result score suggests Audrey performs particularly well at creating a finished matte-lip look. Its high-pigment, full-coverage formula is intended to give a strong cool blue-pink result without sheen. The product’s medium shade depth can offer noticeable colour while remaining distinct from very dark lip looks. Reviews across the range support a generally smooth, velvety appearance, although colour expectations should be checked against multiple swatches where possible.

Skin compatibility

Skin compatibility is scored at 72/100, a moderate result for a lip product. Shea butter and cocoa butter are listed as special ingredients, and some reviewers describe a creamy or moisturising feel. However, other reviewers report that the matte formula feels extremely drying. No complete ingredient list or sensitive-skin testing information was provided, so people with a history of lip sensitivity should check the package label and stop use if discomfort occurs.

Shade range

The shade-range score is 86/100. NYX states that this matte lipstick collection is available in 22 shades, spanning reds, nudes and other matte colours. Audrey itself is a cool, medium-depth blue pink with high pigment, giving it a clear colour identity. Reviews suggest that some shades can appear different from listing photos or expected undertones, so the range is broad but shoppers should compare several real-life swatches before choosing a shade.

How it compares

Within the matte lipstick category, Audrey appears stronger for pigment, finish and straightforward application than for universally comfortable wear. Its 90/100 finish score and 88/100 beauty-result score point to a polished, opaque matte effect, while its 87/100 value score makes the listed 8.94 price appealing. The stated 22-shade collection also supports its 86/100 shade-range score. By contrast, the 71/100 comfort score signals a less consistent experience than users may expect from a creamy matte description. It is best viewed as a colour-and-finish-focused lipstick rather than a no-transfer or universally moisturising formula.

Ranking summary

With an overall score of 84/100, NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey ranks as a strong-value option in the matte lipstick category. Its best results come from finish quality at 90/100, application at 89/100, beauty result at 88/100 and value at 87/100. The high-pigment, full-coverage cool pink shade and convenient stick format give it a clear makeup purpose. Its ranking is held back from an elite position by more mixed comfort at 71/100 and skin compatibility at 72/100, alongside reviews noting dryness, transfer and occasional migration. It is a strong choice for matte colour impact, with practical wear compromises to consider.

Buying advice

Consider NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey if you want a full-coverage, cool blue-pink matte lip in a familiar stick format and are looking for strong performance at a modest listed price. Its best assets are saturated colour, a smooth-looking matte finish and easy application. Before buying, compare independent Audrey swatches with your natural lip colour and preferred undertone, as reviews suggest shades in the range may not always match listing images. If your lips are prone to dryness, review the full ingredient label and consider wearing balm underneath. Users needing minimal transfer may prefer to test it first or plan for touch-ups.
84
Overall score

Final verdict

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Lipstick in Audrey is a strong matte lipstick option, earning an 84/100 overall score through its high pigment, full coverage, polished finish and accessible value. The cool mid-tone blue-pink shade gives it a clear place in a colour-focused makeup routine, and the standard bullet format is easy to use. Its main limitation is consistency of comfort and wear: while many users report a creamy, long-lasting experience, others find it drying or prone to transfer. Choose it for a defined matte lip and strong colour payoff, not as a guaranteed transfer-proof or universally cushioning formula.
Back to review

Key topics

NYX Professional Makeup Matte Lipstick Audrey review, NYX Audrey mid-tone blue pink lipstick, NYX matte lipstick review, cool pink matte lipstick, full coverage matte lipstick, cruelty free lipstick, NYX lipstick shades

Frequently asked questions

Is NYX Professional Makeup Matte Lipstick in Audrey a good matte lipstick?
Based on its 84/100 overall score, strong 86/100 effectiveness score and 90/100 finish-quality score, Audrey appears to be a strong matte lipstick option. It is positioned as a high-pigment, full-coverage stick with a cool mid-tone blue-pink colour. The main trade-off is inconsistent comfort and transfer resistance across reviews.
What colour is NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey?
Audrey is labelled as a mid-tone blue pink. Its listed undertone is cool, its depth is medium, and its pigment intensity is high. As with any lipstick shade, the final appearance can vary with natural lip colour, lighting and the rest of the makeup look, so checking independent swatches may be useful.
Is NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey drying?
The available feedback is mixed. The product description presents the formula as creamy and not dry-feeling, and some reviewers found shades in the range comfortable or moisturising. However, other buyers reported significant dryness. The skin-compatibility score of 72/100 and comfort score of 71/100 suggest comfort is not equally consistent for every wearer.
How long does NYX Matte Lipstick last?
Longevity is rated 81/100, indicating generally good wear rather than fully transfer-proof performance. Several reviews describe the colour as long-lasting or staying in place through drinks and extended wear. Other feedback notes transfer to cups, migration and reduced wear after eating, so touch-ups may still be needed depending on the occasion.
Is NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey easy to apply?
Yes, the 86/100 ease-of-use score and 89/100 application score indicate a user-friendly format. It is a conventional twist-up lipstick stick described as smooth-gliding and creamy. Because the pigment is high and the finish is matte, applying carefully around the lip line—or using liner first—may help keep the finished shape more precise.
Does NYX Matte Lipstick offer good value?
With a value score of 87/100 and a listed price of 8.94, this lipstick appears competitively positioned for buyers seeking full-coverage matte colour. The strong finish, application and customer-satisfaction scores support its value case. Buyers who need reliably transfer-resistant wear or consistently cushioning comfort may find its compromises more important than its price.
Is NYX Matte Lipstick cruelty-free?
NYX Professional Makeup states that it is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free brand and that it does not test on animals. That supplied brand information supports the product’s 84/100 ethical-transparency score. No further sustainability, packaging recyclability or full formulation-transparency details were provided for this specific lipstick.
Who should avoid NYX Matte Lipstick Audrey?
This may be less suitable for people who strongly dislike matte textures, require minimal transfer during meals, or know that their lips become uncomfortable with drier lip colours. It may also be a less direct match for shoppers seeking a warm pink, sheer coverage or a glossy finish. The cool, medium-depth Audrey shade is a specific colour preference.

Related Guides & Rankings

Rimmel Lasting Finish 8HR Lip Liner Cappuccino... Rimmel Lasting Finish 8HR Lip Liner Cappuccino... Milani Color Statement Lipstick Pink Frost Review Milani Color Statement Lipstick Pink Frost Review Burt's Bees Red Dahlia Tinted Lip Balm Review Burt's Bees Red Dahlia Tinted Lip Balm Review NYX Slim Lip Liner Pencil Nude Beige Review NYX Slim Lip Liner Pencil Nude Beige Review